A complete issue · 36 pages · 1919
Life — October 23, 1919
# Analysis of Life Magazine Cover, October 23, 1919 The main cartoon titled "A Reincarnation" depicts a man in work clothes standing beside a gravestone marked "AUTOCRACY / DIED / NOVEMBER 11, 1918"—referencing the armistice ending World War I and the collapse of European monarchies. The figure appears to represent either returning militarism or authoritarian leadership being resurrected in post-war society. The elaborate header illustration shows cherubs and classical figures, suggesting themes of power and governance. The satire warns that despite autocracy's apparent death, its spirit may persist or return—a commentary on anxieties about whether wartime authoritarian controls would truly end, or whether new forms of tyranny might emerge during post-war reconstruction and social upheaval in 1919.
# Analysis This page is **primarily a vintage automobile advertisement** for United States Tires' "Royal Cord" brand, not political satire. The illustration shows a 1919-era social scene at what appears to be a country club or park gathering, with well-dressed figures and automobiles. The cartoon depicts leisure-class life of the period—men in suits and hats, women in fashionable dress, vehicles prominently displayed. The advertisement emphasizes the tire's durability and reliability, claiming superior "hidden values" that justify the product's quality through long-term road performance. The satire, if present, is gentle and commercial rather than political—it's aspirational advertising dressed in humor, appealing to consumers' desires for status and reliability. The focus is entirely on product promotion, not social or political commentary.
# Analysis This is an advertisement for the Apperson Bros. Automobile Company's "Eight" model, titled "A PERSON with Eight Legged Ability." The satire plays on the car's name by depicting a literal eight-legged creature (appearing to be an insect or spider-like being) driving the automobile. The joke is a visual pun: the car is called an "Eight," so the advertiser humorously illustrates it being driven by something with eight legs. The ad emphasizes the car's capabilities, claiming it can handle various driving conditions and challenges. The surrounding landscape sketch shows the vehicle navigating rough terrain, supporting the message about its durability and performance. This represents early automotive advertising's use of wordplay and illustrated humor to make products memorable to readers of *Life* magazine.
# Analysis This page contains **primarily advertisements** (Vindex Shirts, Bayer Aspirin, Evans's Depilatory) interspersed with editorial content. The central element is a letter **"From Our Friends"** addressing a strike—likely the steel strike referenced in the text. The unsigned letter (possibly from Life's editor or a notable figure) expresses sympathy for striking workers while urging patience and warning against "radical" elements. The writer promises to support the strikers' cause. The left sidebar shows a **"Soldier Memorials"** advertisement depicting a military figure on horseback, emphasizing wartime sacrifice—contextualizing labor unrest in post-WWI America. The overall message appears to balance **pro-labor sentiment with caution against radical action**, a characteristic moderate position during America's volatile early-1920s labor period when fears of Bolshevism were high.
# Analysis This is a **advertisement, not satire or political commentary**. It's a full-page ad from the Irish Linen Society (Belfast, Ireland) promoting linen products for formal occasions. The image shows a man in formal evening wear at an elegant dinner table, illustrating the "formal use" context mentioned in the text. The ad emphasizes that Irish linen's "age-old tradition and time-honored usage" make it essential for proper formal entertaining, particularly for holiday occasions like Thanksgiving and Christmas. The slogan "There is no substitute for Linen" appears in a decorative banner. The advertisement urges readers to purchase Irish linen early, noting supply is limited at better stores. This is straightforward product marketing, not political satire or commentary.
This page contains two advertisements rather than editorial cartoons or satire. The left side advertises **Listerine**, marketed as "The Safe Antiseptic" by Lambert Pharmacal Company (St. Louis). The ad explains that Listerine is a boric acid solution that remains on skin surfaces, providing antiseptic protection without irritating tissues. A plate diagram shows the non-volatile contents left after evaporation, demonstrating the product's effectiveness for wound dressing. The right side advertises **Milo Violets**—delicately scented gold-tipped cigarettes (25 or 10 box, $2.90)—and **The Homestead**, a luxury resort in Hot Springs, Virginia, featuring an 18-hole golf course, natural springs, and health facilities at 2,500 feet elevation. Both are typical early 20th-century product and tourism advertisements with no satirical content.
# Page Analysis: Life Magazine This page is primarily **advertising**, not satire or political commentary. The dominant image shows a hand holding a large pyralin (celluloid) frying pan—a DuPont product advertisement for "Genuine Ivory Py-Ra-Lin." The left column contains a fictional vignette about the daughters of "A. B. and C. D. Morley-Wells, the famous novelists," discussing their parents' collaborative writing process. This appears to be a humorous short story or sketch, likely satirizing literary couples who work together. Below is a separate advertisement for "Boston Garter" hosiery by the George Frost Company, emphasizing comfort and quality. The page primarily demonstrates how **Life magazine blended editorial content with advertising**, using celebrity references and humor to sell consumer goods to its affluent readership.
# Advertisement Analysis This is a **Mimeograph machine advertisement** from *Life* magazine. The image shows two men operating an early mimeograph device (a stencil-based duplicating machine). The ad's appeal to "Cogitate!" uses classical rhetoric—invoking Mercury, the Roman god of commerce and speed—to pitch the Mimeograph as essential modern business equipment. The copywriter argues that while "forward work" is primary, **time and money savings rank second**, and the Mimeograph delivers both by rapidly duplicating forms, drawings, and documents (5,000 copies per hour claimed). The ad targets commercial and educational institutions, positioning the device as a competitive necessity. A.B. Dick Company (Chicago and New York) published a promotional booklet available on request. This reflects early-20th-century industrial marketing: selling efficiency tools to businesses by appealing to competitive advantage and speed.
# "Some Girl!" - Life Magazine Satire Page This page satirizes the modern educated woman of the early 20th century. The decorative "LIFE" header features dancing women in classical poses, setting a lighthearted tone. The poem by Clinton Scollard describes a woman who is intellectually accomplished but impractical: she reads about cooking rather than actually cooking, knows languages and science, but lacks common sense. She's "crusty" and argumentative yet somehow charming. The illustration depicts a social scene where two women visit an older gentleman. The caption contrasts reactions: "What a handsome young fellow!" versus "What a nice-looking old gentleman!"—likely mocking how women judge men's appearance differently based on wealth or status. The overall satire targets the "New Woman"—educated, opinionated, but still bound by social conventions and superficiality.
# "The Printers' Strike" This page addresses a printers' strike in New York City. The editorial defends publishers and "decent American workmen" against what it calls "radical members of unions" and "lawless, foreign" elements seeking to destroy American institutions through anarchism. The cartoon below depicts this conflict: businessmen on the left appear calm and controlled, while on the right, figures amid flames and chaos represent the strike's violence and disruption. The caption—about "Smith" losing his fortune and uncertainty over who serves whom—satirizes the social upheaval and role reversals the strike threatens. Life presents the strike as fundamentally un-American, positioning itself with established order against labor radicalism portrayed as foreign-influenced anarchism.
# "Life" Magazine Page Analysis This page from *Life* magazine contains several satirical pieces: **"Reality" (top):** A poem contrasting childhood dreams with adult reality, illustrated with a Kansas farm scene—suggesting the disappointment of prairie life versus romantic expectations. **"Distance" (middle):** A brief joke where aviators discuss travel to Paris. The "Second Aviator's" response—mentioning "one soviet government, two counter-revolutions and a mandatory straight ahead"—satirizes post-WWI European political instability and the difficulty of travel through war-torn regions. **"Words" (bottom):** A cartoon showing men in top hats (likely politicians or committee members) discussing investigations, mocking bureaucratic committees investigating other committees—reflecting cynicism about government inefficiency. **Lower cartoon:** A social joke about a man's appearance and marriage, typical of *Life's* humor about domestic life and courtship.
# "Some Open Letters" — Life Magazine Satire This page features three satirical open letters addressed to public figures: 1. **To Judge E. H. Gary**: Praises him for running his business without "wild asses" (labor unions) interfering, calling his anti-union stance a "remarkable achievement" against "anarchy and bloodshed." 2. **To King Albert of Belgium**: Congratulates him on being a king during uncertain times, noting monarchs face elimination—a dark joke about royal obsolescence. 3. **To Gabriele d'Annunzio**: Sarcastically criticizes the Italian military adventurer for disrupting armies and "discomfiting the Allies," mockingly warning that Fanny will "grab New York" from Hearst. The accompanying illustration shows a man felling a massive oak tree, quoting Henry VI—likely symbolizing destruction of established order. The cartoons employ heavy irony to critique labor suppression, militarism, and political adventurism.