Legion of Super-Heroes #16

This November 1985 issue of Legion of Super-Heroes features one of the most striking covers of its era, with Steve Lightle's art setting a genuinely haunting tone. Dominating the left side is an enormous, eerie yellow-green face — one tear-filled green eye gazing outward — while a desperate Supergirl in her red-and-blue costume reaches and tumbles across the vivid crimson-and-pink background, her expression a mix of anguish and struggle. Paul Levitz, Steve Lightle, and Bob Smith bring their considerable talents to "Baptism," and this cover alone — all raw emotion and bold design — makes it easy to see why this creative team's run resonated so strongly with fans in 1985.