A complete issue · 16 pages · 1882
Judge — May 27, 1882
# "The Great Duel" (May 27, 1882) This cartoon satirizes a confrontation between two gentlemen, likely political or social figures of 1882, depicted as antagonists in a formal duel scenario. The figures wear "Champion" labeled containers as heads—a visual metaphor suggesting their arguments are hollow or trivial. The absurd weaponry and theatrical posing mock the ritualized nature of gentlemen's honor disputes of the era. The exchange—one calling the other a "dirty, low blackguard," the other responding "You're a liar!"—represents pointless name-calling rather than substantive debate. The inset showing a Union Club gathering suggests this may reference a specific social or political dispute within elite New York circles. The satire critiques both the participants' pettiness and the anachronistic tradition of dueling to defend honor, treating serious conflict as comedic theater.