comicbooks.com Join Free
All Star Western #74 cover
Cover: Gil Kane & Joe Giella

All Star Western #74

Dec 1953 · DC · 0.10 USD
☆ Be the first to review + Add to your collection — Join free

In "Sheriff Wanted," Professor Phineas makes a dramatic return—this time not in a balloon, but in a glider—prompting skepticism from a dismissive Colonel who refuses to take the craft seriously. When a warning arrives that the Arapaho have rigged a remote outpost with explosives, Phineas and Foley must take to the skies in the glider to intercept the Colonel and prevent disaster. Written by John Broome and illustrated by Irwin Hasen with inks by Bernard Sachs, this 1953 adventure blends frontier tension with early aviation daring, all capped by a striking cover by Gil Kane and Joe Giella.

Contains 6 stories
Sheriff Wanted
5.67 pp · Western-Frontier
Trigger Twins

In "Sheriff Wanted," Walt’s sudden resignation as sheriff sends shockwaves through the frontier town—until Wayne, his old friend and reluctant hero, tracks him down at Tumble Rocks, their childhood haunt. What begins as a moment of cowardice turns into a daring plan when Wayne, posing as a quiet storekeeper, takes on the Larango Gang unarmed, only to be captured—prompting Walt to ride in and deliver a hard-fought, gritty showdown.

Weddings -- Choctaw Indian Style!
1 pp · Non-Fiction, Western-Frontier
Challenge of Black Cloud!
6 pp · Western-Frontier

In "Challenge of Black Cloud!" from All Star Western #74, the lone warrior Strong Bow arrives in a Sioux valley torn by raids, where he’s summoned to face a deadly trial to save his life. As he endures the Trial of 100 Arrows and the Trial of Three Lances, he uncovers a hidden betrayal—Chief Shining Moon’s father is being poisoned by the treacherous Black Cloud. With the chief on the brink, Strong Bow must confront the villain in a fierce clash that could change the valley’s fate. Shining Moon watches, her eyes on the warrior’s return.

Wings over the Prairie!
5.67 pp · Western-Frontier

In "Wings over the Prairie!", Professor Phineas returns from his balloon days, now testing a glider with bold ambitions—and a skeptical Colonel who dismisses him as a crackpot. When a warning arrives that the Arapaho have rigged a remote outpost with explosives, Phineas and Foley take to the skies to intercept the Colonel, using the glider’s daring flight to outmaneuver danger and ignite a desperate plan.

The Sacred Indian Pole
1 pp · Non-Fiction, Western-Frontier
Decoy at Canyon Pass!
6 pp · Western-Frontier
Johnny Thunder [John Tane]

In "Decoy at Canyon Pass!", schoolteacher John Tane finds himself trapped in a deadly ruse when the Drygulch Gang stages a fake Johnny Thunder to lure the real one. Tied to a slingshot-tree with a rope rigged to send him flying to his doom, Tane must think fast—using his eyeglasses as a lens to burn through the rope and escape into the river. When he emerges, guns blazing, the truth is revealed: John Tane is Johnny Thunder in disguise. The gang’s plan unravels, and the outlaw’s reputation for outsmarting his foes holds true once more.

ComicBooks.com Value

Our Model is In Beta
Raw (Good) $21
CGC 8.0 · 2 in census $206
CGC 7.5 none in existence
CGC 7.0 none in existence
CGC 6.5 none in existence
CGC 6.0 · 1 in census $94
Our model’s value — refined as new sales data arrives · CGC census counts shown where available

Find on

Search eBay for All Star Western #74
No confirmed live listings for this exact issue right now — this opens an eBay search.

Sell my copy

Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.

We Buy Collections ▸
Fast, fair offers · we handle grading & shipping

Cast · 1 character

Full credits

cover pencils Gil Kane
cover inks Joe Giella

Reprints

Reprinted in All Favourites Comic #24 (1961), Katan #10 (1967), Johnny Thunder #2 (1973), Tomahawk #8/1974 (1974), Tomahawk #8/1974 (1974), Tomahawk #4/1975 (1975), Tomahawk #10/1975 (1975), Tomahawk #10/1975 (1975), Tomahawk #6/1976 (1976), Tomahawk #5/1977 (1977), Tomahawk #4/1977 (1977), Jonah Hex #3/1985 (1985), Jonah Hex #11 (1987)

Reviews

Reader reviews

No reader reviews yet.