X-Factor #44

Sep 1989 · Marvel · 1.00 USD; 1.25 CAD; 0.50 GBP

📊 ~31,540 copies sold its debut month

☆ Be the first to review + Add to your collection — Join free

“Another World! (Judgement War Part Two)”

★ 1st appearance — Vlon★ 1st appearance — Dykon

About this Issue

X-Factor #44 is the second chapter of the seven-part 'Judgement War' arc, Louise Simonson's ambitious 1989 space opera that used an alien civil war as a direct allegorical mirror for mutant persecution on Earth — the Chosen (physically 'perfect' mutants who could pass as human) versus the Rejects (visibly 'monstrous' mutants), with a third pacifist group, the Beginagains, caught between them. The issue introduces a cluster of alien characters who would populate the arc through its conclusion, including Lord Palik, and the Rejects Ryest, Vlon, and Wilghe, along with the robot ZZ-105 and the Beginagain Dykon. It also deepens one of the arc's most consequential subplots: Iceman's head-trauma amnesia, which Simonson uses to examine Bobby Drake's identity from the outside in, stripped of his own history. The 'Judgement War' arc as a whole is also the storyline in which Ship — the sentient vessel X-Factor had seized from Apocalypse — is revealed to have been created not by Apocalypse but by the Celestials themselves, a retcon that recontextualizes the cosmic hierarchy underpinning the entire Simonson run.

In "Another World! (Judgement War Part Two)," X-Factor splinters across a war-torn planet, each member drawn into a different faction with uncertain loyalties. As Beast finds himself among the Rejects—unaware Jean is also imprisoned—Archangel and Iceman face captivity with the Chosen, Cyclops aligns with the pacifist Beginagin, and Seera teams up with Nathan Christopher. Written by Louise Simonson and illustrated by Paul Smith, with inks by Allen Milgrom, colors by Tom Vincent, and letters by Joe Rosen, the cover by Paul Smith captures the tension of a fractured team in a world at war.

writer Louise Simonson · artist Paul Smith · inker Allen Milgrom · colorist Tom Vincent · letterer Joe Rosen · cover Paul Smith

ComicBooks.com Value

Our Model is In Beta

Raw (VF) $0

Flagged key issue — estimate limited by sparse sales.

Our model’s value — refined as new sales data arrives · CGC census counts shown where available

Find on ebay

Search eBay for X-Factor #44 ▸

No confirmed live listings for this exact issue right now — this opens an eBay search.

Sell my copy

Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.

We Buy Collections ▸

Fast, fair offers · we handle grading & shipping

History

Written by Louise Simonson with pencil layouts by Paul Smith (finishing his own inks on the cover) and interior finishes by Al Milgrom, the issue was edited by Bob Harras under editor-in-chief Tom DeFalco and released on May 23, 1989, with a September 1989 cover date. Paul Smith — best known for his celebrated run on Uncanny X-Men earlier in the decade — returned to the X-universe for the full 'Judgement War' arc, which occupied Simonson's X-Factor from issues #43 through #50. The arc followed immediately on the heels of the 'Inferno' crossover, meaning the creative team was simultaneously managing Jean Grey's Madelyne Pryor/Phoenix personality crisis (an unresolved thread from that event) while building an entirely new alien cast — an unusually demanding editorial situation for a monthly title.

Trivia · 8 facts

Title: 'Judgement War Part 2: Another World!' — the second installment of a seven-part arc running through X-Factor #43–50 (1989).
First appearances in this issue: Lord Palik (Chosen villain), Ryest (Reject), Vlon (Reject), Wilghe (Reject), Dykon (Beginagain), and ZZ-105 (Princess Seera's robot companion).
Written by Louise Simonson; pencil layouts by Paul Smith (who also fully penciled and inked the cover); interior finishes by Al Milgrom; colored by Tom Vincent; lettered by Joe Rosen; edited by Bob Harras.
The issue establishes the three-faction conflict at the heart of the arc: the Chosen (physically 'perfect' mutants), the Rejects (visibly mutated outcasts), and the pacifist Beginagains — a deliberate allegorical structure echoing mutant prejudice on Earth.
Iceman (Bobby Drake) awakens with amnesia after a blow to the head in #43; the Chosen classify him as a 'Dualer' — a subset who appear physically perfect but possess a monstrous alternate form — establishing his identity arc for the remainder of 'Judgement War.'
Cyclops, presumed dead after a Celestial landing in the previous issue, survives and falls in with the Beginagain Pacifists, who explain that the Celestials periodically return to pass judgment on the planet and destroy its inhabitants if they are found wanting.
The Celestial Gammenon the Gatherer is present on the planet's surface throughout the issue, maintaining the cosmic stakes of the arc and connecting the story to Jack Kirby's Eternal/Celestial mythology.
The entire 'Judgement War' arc — including this issue — was collected in X-Factor Epic Collection Vol. 4: Judgement War (Marvel, 2023), making it readily accessible in trade format.