X-Factor #4
X-Factor #4 (May 1986) marks the first full appearance of Frenzy — Joanna Cargill — a super-strong, near-invulnerable mutant who would go on to serve as a recurring antagonist across three decades of X-Men comics, eventually joining the Acolytes and later the X-Men themselves. The issue also deepens the central moral tension of the early series: X-Factor publicly poses as mutant hunters while secretly protecting the very mutants it pretends to persecute, a contradiction that Jean Grey openly wrestles with here. As only the fourth chapter of Bob Layton's opening arc, it introduces the organizational shadow behind Tower and Frenzy — an unnamed 'Master' whose identity will soon be revealed as Apocalypse — laying the groundwork for one of the most consequential villain debuts in X-Men history.
In "Trials and Errors," Beast grapples with the challenges of life as a human after years of being a mutant, struggling to find his place within X-Factor. When a rough training session pushes him to flee, he’s captured by Frenzy, who intends to deliver him to her mysterious master—forcing the team to step in and bring him back. Written by Bob Layton and illustrated by Keith Pollard, with inks by Joe Rubinstein, colors by Petra Scotese, and letters by Joe Rosen, this 1986 issue captures a pivotal moment in Beast’s journey, all framed by Ron Frenz’s dynamic cover art.
This exact issue on ebay
CGC 9.8 ▾ $50–$90 6 listings
Raw — MINT ▾ $4.41–$4.44 2 listings
Raw — NM ▾ $4.99–$24 11 listings
Raw — VF/NM ▾ $3.99–$35.95 4 listings
Raw — VF+ ▾ $6–$12.75 3 listings
Raw — FN ▾ $10.98–$24 2 listings
Raw / ungraded ▾ $1–$29.99 35 listings
More listings for this title
Sell my copy
Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.
We Buy Collections ▸History
X-Factor launched in February 1986 under writer Bob Layton, who conceived the series as a reunion of the five founding X-Men — an ambition complicated by the need to free Angel, Beast, and Iceman from the Defenders (whose monthly series was cancelled to accomplish this) and to engineer the resurrection of Jean Grey. Layton wrote only the first five issues before handing the title to Louise Simonson; issue #4 thus falls squarely in his brief opening tenure, with interior art by layout artist Keith Pollard and finisher Josef Rubinstein — a different penciling team than regular artist Jackson Guice, who had contributed to earlier issues — and a cover by Ron Frenz and Rubinstein. The book was edited by Bob Harras under editor-in-chief Jim Shooter, and notably operated out of a separate Marvel editorial department from Chris Claremont's Uncanny X-Men, a distinction that generated real creative friction from the series' outset.
Trivia · 7 facts
- First appearance of Frenzy (Joanna Cargill), a mutant with superhuman strength and near-impenetrable skin, created by writer Bob Layton and artist Keith Pollard.
- Frenzy is introduced as field leader of an unnamed criminal organization (soon to be revealed as Apocalypse's Alliance of Evil), sent to recruit — or forcibly conscript — the fire-starting trainee Rusty Collins.
- Tower (Edward Pasternak), the size-changing mercenary who first appeared in X-Factor #2, returns here as Frenzy's subordinate; the two are linked to an unseen 'Master' whose identity is not yet disclosed in this issue.
- Timeshadow is referenced behind-the-scenes in this issue (per the Marvel Appendix) but does not appear on-panel until X-Factor #5; some retail sources incorrectly list #4 as his first appearance.
- The story is titled 'Trials and Error!' and was written by Bob Layton with art by Keith Pollard (layouts) and Josef Rubinstein (inks), and a cover by Ron Frenz and Josef Rubinstein.
- The issue highlights the psychological strain on Scott Summers (Cyclops): Artie Maddicks inadvertently projects an image of Madelyne Pryor from Scott's mind, underscoring the ongoing subplot of Scott having abandoned his wife and infant son to rejoin Jean Grey.
- Jean Grey's moral doubt about the X-Factor deception — posing as mutant hunters while actually protecting mutants — is foregrounded as a central character conflict, with Jean questioning whether their cover operation is doing more harm than good.
Cast · 19 characters
Full credits
Full plot ⚠ may contain spoilers
▸ Reveal full plot — may contain spoilers
Beast tries to readjust to looking human again. After a training session goes bad, Rusty runs away from X-Factor but falls into the arms of Frenzy who plans on taking him back to her master. X-Factor intervenes and Rusty returns to the fold.
Plot details indexed by the Grand Comics Database (CC BY-SA).
Key issues in X-Factor
Variants (2)
Reviews
Reader reviews
No reader reviews yet.