comicbooks.com Join Free
HomeAll-Star Comics › #22
All-Star Comics #22 cover
Cover: Frank Harry

All-Star Comics #22

Oct 1944 · DC · 0.10 USD
☆ Be the first to review + Add to your collection — Join free

In "The Test of Time! [Introduction]," the Atom travels back to Colonial America during the Salem witch trials, where he encounters Mother Rathlow, a woman accused of witchcraft due to her knowledge of herbs. When a mob threatens her, he intervenes in his disguise, only to be mistaken for a wizard himself—leaving her in awe as he begins to vanish before her eyes. Written by Gardner Fox and illustrated by Joe Gallagher, this 1944 tale blends historical atmosphere with early superhero mysticism, featuring a striking cover by Frank Harry.

Contains 10 stories
The Test of Time! [Introduction]
4 pp · Superhero
Justice Society of America [Hawkman [Carter Hall]Starman [Ted Knight]Johnny ThunderThe Atom [Al Pratt]Dr. Mid-Nite [Dr. Charles McNider]The Spectre [Jim Corrigan]]Conscience of Man (introduction)unnamed young boy

In "The Test of Time! [Introduction]" from All-Star Comics #22 (1944), Dr. Mid-Nite brings a young boy to the JSA after witnessing him attacked for his faith, prompting the heroes to confront a crisis beyond their usual battles. When a mysterious woman appears and offers them a chance to fight injustice across history, the team agrees to a trial—each hurled into past eras of persecution, unaware of their present identities, to stand against hatred and bigotry.

The Test of Time! Chapter 1
6 pp · Superhero
Hawkman [Carter Hallaka Ga]Tow (caveman)Mok (caveman)

In "The Test of Time! Chapter 1," Hawkman finds himself stranded in the stone age, mistaken for a giant bird by a tribe who sees him as both threat and meal. After fending off an attack and a bear, he earns their trust and is named Ga—only to be drawn into a deeper mystery when the tribe prepares to kill an artist who painted a woolly mammoth, believing it to be a real beast. With the artist’s help, Ga must now protect the tribe from the very creature he once thought was only a legend.

The Test of Time! Chapter 2
5 pp · Superhero
Starman [Ted Knightaka Theodoratus]Galen (Theodoratus' aide)Leonidas (General)Phidias (a slave)Xerxes (villain, Persian leader)

In "The Test of Time! Chapter 2," Starman finds himself in ancient Greece in 480 B.C., serving as a Greek soldier in the Strategoi. When he proposes training slaves for battle—despite the generals’ doubts—he takes up the challenge, leading a group into combat where a chance use of his gravity rod turns the tide. As the slaves claim victory and their freedom, their story spreads, igniting a quiet revolution.

"Corn" on the Side
1 pp · Humor
FatSlat
The Test of Time! Chapter 3
6 pp · Humor, Superhero
Johnny ThunderThe Thunderbolt [Archibald]Baron's unnamed daughterunnamed Baron (villain)

In "The Test of Time! Chapter 3," Johnny, stranded in medieval England as a lowly shepherd, endures a brutal flogging before earning an unexpected role as the Baron’s court jester. When the Baron offers him a chance to win favor for the serfs by triumphing in the Knight's Tourney—with help from the Thunderbolt—Johnny rises to the challenge, only to vanish at the moment he’s to be knighted and presented with the Baron’s daughter as his bride.

The Test of Time! Chapter 4
5 pp · Superhero
The Atom [Al Prattaka Nathaniel Pratt]Julie (Nathaniel's wife)Nathaniel's unnamed MotherMother Rathlow (supposed witch)

In "The Test of Time! Chapter 4," Atom finds himself in colonial Salem, where fear of witchcraft runs high. When he discovers a woman named Mother Rathlow trapped in the woods and accused of sorcery due to her knowledge of herbs, he steps in to protect her—disguised as the Atom. As a mob closes in, he tries to reason with them, only to be mistaken for a wizard himself. When he begins to vanish before her eyes, Mother Rathlow is left wondering if he truly is one.

Those Super-Duper Dealers in Unrationed "Corn"
1 pp · Humor
FatSlat
The Test of Time! Chapter 5
5 pp · Superhero
Dr. Mid-Nite [Dr. Charles McNideraka Dr. De Nider]Le Duc De Harigny (a nobelman)Le Duc's unnamed sonDuc D'Ormonde (villain, military commander)

In "The Test of Time! Chapter 5," Dr. Mid-Nite—disguised as the 18th-century physician M'sieu De Nider—finds himself caught between duty and danger in revolutionary Paris, where the fury toward the nobility runs as deep as the bloodshed. As he risks his life to treat a wounded nobleman, he must navigate the volatile streets where fear and vengeance threaten to consume the city, all while trying to keep the people from crossing the line into senseless violence.

The Test of Time! Chapter 6
5 pp · Superhero
The Spectre [Jim Corrigan]Stephen Hare (inventor)Robert Fulton (steamboat inventor)unruly mob (villains)
The Test of Time! Conclusion
3 pp · Superhero
Justice Society of America [Starman [Ted Knight]Dr. Mid-Nite [Dr. Charles McNider]Hawkman [Carter Hall]Johnny ThunderThe Atom [Al Pratt]Wonder Woman [Diana Prince] (cameo)Johnny ThunderThe Spectre [Jim Corrigan]]Conscience of Manunnamed young boy

In "The Test of Time! Conclusion," the Justice Society of America returns to their headquarters after completing their individual missions, only to be met with a profound revelation: Conscience, the mysterious figure who guided them, unveils herself as the Conscience of Man. She emphasizes that true change comes through education, not force, and with that, she vanishes—leaving the heroes to carry her message. Inspired by a young boy whose personal struggle sparked the journey, the JSA takes her words to heart and begins a new mission: teaching in a school, where their impact is immediate and powerful.

ComicBooks.com Value

Our Model is In Beta
Raw (Good) $270
CGC 9.8 · 1 in census $19,887*
CGC 9.6 none in existence
CGC 9.4 · 1 in census $7,937
CGC 9.2 · 1 in census $5,000*
CGC 9.0 · 3 in census $3,613
CGC 8.5 · 2 in census $2,422
Show all 22 grades
CGC 8.0 · 3 in census $1,900*
CGC 7.5 · 4 in census $1,858
CGC 7.0 · 8 in census $1,137
CGC 6.5 · 7 in census $1,137
CGC 6.0 · 9 in census $903
CGC 5.5 · 4 in census $866
CGC 5.0 · 4 in census $866
CGC 4.5 · 8 in census $665
CGC 4.0 · 7 in census $545*
CGC 3.5 · 4 in census $494
CGC 3.0 · 4 in census $353
CGC 2.5 · 5 in census $348*
CGC 2.0 · 2 in census $296*
CGC 1.5 none in existence
CGC 1.0 · 2 in census $190*
CGC 0.5 · 2 in census $149*
* estimate — limited direct-sales data at this grade
Our model’s value — refined as new sales data arrives · CGC census counts shown where available

This exact issue on

CGC 6 $1,295 1 listing CGC 5.5 $1,300 1 listing CGC 1.5 $475 1 listing
Raw / ungraded $17.59–$99.99 2 listings
Verified matches for All-Star Comics #22 · eBay asking prices, seen 29 days ago

Sell my copy

Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.

We Buy Collections ▸
Fast, fair offers · we handle grading & shipping

Cast · 2 characters

Full credits

artist, inker Joe Gallagher
cover pencils, inks Frank Harry

Reprints

Reprinted in Justice League of America #39 (1965), All Star Comics Archives #5 (2000), Take That, Adolf!: The Fighting Comic Books of the Second World War #[nn] (2017)

Key issues in All-Star Comics

Reviews

Reader reviews

No reader reviews yet.