A complete issue · 16 pages · 1887
Judge — May 7, 1887
# "The Second Term Question" This 1887 Judge cartoon satirizes the "Second Term Question"—whether President Cleveland should seek reelection. The illustration shows a lavishly dressed gentleman (likely representing a political suitor or office-seeker) courting a woman labeled as representing a second presidential term, with the Capitol building visible in the background. The caption reads: "Would you accept a Second Term, my pretty Maid?" and her response "Nobody asked me, Sir," she said." The satire mocks the presumption of politicians assuming the presidency (feminized as an available "maid") would naturally accept their advances. The ornate, almost ridiculous costume of the suitor emphasizes the exaggerated self-importance of ambitious politicians. It's a commentary on political ambition and the audacity of career-seeking during the Gilded Age.
# Judge Magazine Page Analysis This page contains political commentary rather than traditional cartoons. The main illustrated figures appear to be caricatured politicians in two sketches—one showing a grotesque face (likely representing a political opponent) and another depicting figures near a street lamp. The text discusses various 1890s political figures and issues: Mr. Conkling's refusal to make speeches, allegations about bandits in Cuba and John Slocum, William Walter Phelps as a Republican vice-presidential candidate, and commentary on Mr. Blaine's political health. References to "the Democratic newspaper" and disputes suggest partisan debate during a presidential election cycle. The satire mocks political figures' behavior, ambitions, and contradictions—typical of Judge's irreverent approach to American politics. Without clearer dating or bylines visible, exact figures remain difficult to definitively identify.
