The Silver Surfer #3
Silver Surfer #3 (December 1968) is the debut issue of Mephisto, one of the most consequential villains in Marvel history — a Faust-derived demonic tempter whose influence would eventually stretch from Ghost Rider's origin to Spider-Man's marriage in 'One More Day,' making this issue the source point for decades of infernal Marvel storytelling. The narrative itself is a near-perfect distillation of what Stan Lee was attempting with the entire Silver Surfer series: a morality play pitting cosmic nobility against absolute corruption, in which Mephisto kidnaps the Surfer's beloved Shalla-Bal to try to break his spirit and claim his soul, only to fail — leaving him 'stymied, not defeated,' and establishing the template for every Faustian encounter that followed. The issue also arrived in a format deliberately distinct from the rest of the Marvel line: a 68-page squarebound giant priced at 25 cents, double the length and more than double the cost of a standard 12-cent comic, which reinforced the series' self-conscious ambition to be taken seriously as literary science fiction. As a Silver Age key that directly birthed a villain who now sits at the center of MCU speculation, the issue stands as an early example of how a single comic can plant seeds that flower across an entire shared universe for more than half a century.
In "The Power and the Prize!", Stan Lee and Gene Colan deliver a chilling tale of identity and deception, where a man’s discovery of a crashed alien ship sets off a chain of unsettling revelations. When he tries to warn the Space Agency, the confrontation with Professor Crater takes a shocking turn—only to reveal that the real mystery lies in the language of the alien’s log, and the man himself may be the one who’s been hiding in plain sight. The story’s tension builds with Paul Reinman’s inks, Bill Everett’s colors, and Sam Rosen’s crisp lettering, all framed by John Buscema’s dynamic cover and Joe Sinnott’s sharp inks.
In "The Power and the Prize!", the Silver Surfer, haunted by his rage and the chaos he's unleashed on Earth, finds himself drawn into a dark bargain with Mephisto. Tempted by a vision of Shalla Bal and the promise of power beyond measure, the Surfer must confront the cost of his desires as demons close in on his soul.
In a quiet moment of discovery, a man stumbles upon a crashed spaceship and uncovers a log hinting at an alien disguise. When he tries to warn the Space Agency, Professor Crater’s sudden hostility forces him to question everything—especially when the truth of the log’s language begins to unravel. With the Watcher observing from afar, the line between alien and human blurs in a story of identity, deception, and the cost of being believed.
ComicBooks.com Value
Show all 22 grades ▾
This exact issue on ebay
CGC 9 ▾ $1,180–$2,800 3 listings
CGC 7 ▾ $495–$600 2 listings
CGC 4 ▾ $299–$350 3 listings
CGC ▾ $369–$450 2 listings
Raw / ungraded ▾ $4.99–$620 25 listings
More listings for this title
Read it digitally
Sell my copy
Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.
We Buy Collections ▸History
When Marvel expanded its line in the late 1960s, Stan Lee — who regarded the Silver Surfer as his most personally meaningful character — was given the title and immediately assigned John Buscema as penciler rather than the series' co-originator Jack Kirby, who already had more assignments than he could handle; this decision reportedly contributed to Kirby's growing disillusionment with Marvel before his eventual move to DC. Lee conceived Mephisto specifically as the Surfer's thematic opposite: where the Surfer embodies selfless nobility, Mephisto represents pure corrupting temptation, and Lee deliberately named the character after Mephistopheles from Goethe's Faust rather than using the biblical Satan — a choice that provided plausible deniability under the Comics Code Authority, which in 1968 still prohibited direct depictions of religious figures and ridiculed religion. Buscema inked by Joe Sinnott handled the lead story, while the issue's backup 'Tales of the Watcher' feature — 'Why Won't They Believe Me?' — was penciled by Gene Colan and inked by Paul Reinman, and the letters column already featured a note from then-fan and future comics writer Tony Isabella.
Trivia · 8 facts
- First appearance of Mephisto (Earth-616), cover-dated December 1968, on sale September 1968; created by Stan Lee and John Buscema, modeled on Mephistopheles of the Faust legend.
- Lead story titled 'The Power and the Prize!' — written by Stan Lee, penciled by John Buscema, inked by Joe Sinnott; backup 'Tales of the Watcher' story penciled by Gene Colan, inked by Paul Reinman.
- A 68-page squarebound 'giant' format priced at 25 cents — nearly double the length of a standard Marvel comic of the era (which ran 36 pages at 12 cents); the first seven issues of the series used this format before reverting to standard size with issue #8.
- Plot: Mephisto, drawn to the Silver Surfer's pure soul, kidnaps Shalla-Bal from Zenn-La and brings her to his infernal realm to coerce the Surfer into submission; the Surfer resists every temptation and defeats Mephisto's demons, but cannot prevent Mephisto from sending Shalla-Bal back to Zenn-La as a parting cruelty.
- Mephisto went on to appear in Silver Surfer #8–9 and #16–17 within the same original run, then expanded to become a recurring antagonist for Thor, Ghost Rider, Spider-Man, Doctor Strange, and Doctor Doom across Marvel's publishing history.
- The letters column in the issue includes a letter from future comics writer Tony Isabella, making this a minor footnote in comics-industry biography.
- The issue has been reprinted numerous times, including Marvel Masterworks #15 (1990), Essential Silver Surfer #1 (1998, black and white), the Silver Surfer Omnibus Vol. 1 (2007), Marvel Masterworks: The Silver Surfer Vol. 1 (2010), and a 2026 Marvel Facsimile Edition reproducing it in its original squarebound format.
- Mephisto's first live-action screen portrayals drew directly on his Ghost Rider connection — Peter Fonda played the character in the 2007 Ghost Rider film — while his MCU debut finally arrived in the 2025 Disney+ series Ironheart, voiced by Sacha Baron Cohen.
Full credits
Reprints
Reprinted in L'Incredibile Devil #4 (1970), L'Incredibile Devil #5 (1970), L'Incredibile Devil #6 (1970), Strange #12 (1970), Strange #13 (1971), Strange #14 (1971), The Super-Heroes #5 (1975), The Super-Heroes #6 (1975), Astonishing Tales #31 (1975), Bring on the Bad Guys: Origins of the Marvel Comics Villains #[nn] (1976), Bring on the Bad Guys: Origins of the Marvel Comics Villains #[nn] (1976), Nova #5 (1978), Star Wars Weekly #21 (1978), Nova #6 (1978), Captain America #8 (1980), Fantasy Masterpieces #3 (1980), Strange Spécial Origines #151 (1982), Return of the Jedi Weekly #119 (1985), Marvel Masterworks #15 (1990), Silver Surfer #25 (1991), Marvel Klassik #2 (1998), Essential Silver Surfer #1 (1998), Marvel : Les origines #3 (2004), Silver Surfer Omnibus #1 (2007) + 18 more
Key issues in The Silver Surfer
Reviews
Reader reviews
No reader reviews yet.