Superman's Pal, Jimmy Olsen #38
Superman's Pal, Jimmy Olsen #38 (July 1959) is a compact showcase of the Silver Age formula that made the series one of DC's most distinctive titles: absurdist premises played straight, Jimmy's comic helplessness before the woman in his life, and Superman as a deus-ex-machina whose powers are cheerfully misused to cook food at super-speed or build a wedding umbrella from his cape. Most significantly, the issue contains 'Jimmy Olsen's Wedding!'—a dream-sequence 'imaginary story' in which Jimmy marries Lucy Lane, one of the earliest explorations of the Jimmy-Lucy relationship after Lucy's debut just two issues earlier in #36. That story established the push-pull dynamic—Lucy's jealousy of Superman versus Jimmy's devotion to him—that would define the couple's on-again, off-again courtship for years, recurring in later imaginary tales and eventually serving as the template for issue #100's (briefly) permanent wedding.
In "The MC of the Midnight Scare Theater!", Jimmy Olsen takes a mysterious pill from the eccentric Dr. Falke, hoping it’ll help him win the Daily Planet’s eating contest and impress Lucy. But the pill’s strange effects soon spiral into something far stranger than he bargained for—especially when the contest venue transforms into a surreal, haunted theater. Written by Robert Bernstein and brought to life with Curt Swan’s crisp art and John Giunta’s dynamic inks, this 1959 classic features a cover by Curt Swan and Stan Kaye that perfectly captures the eerie, playful tone of the tale.
Sell my copy
Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.
We Buy Collections ▸History
The issue sits squarely in the tenure of writer Robert Bernstein and penciler Curt Swan, the creative pairing that defined the series through its first decade. Swan, the series' principal artist for those years, drew all three main stories, with inking duties split between John Forte and John Giunta depending on the story. The public-service filler 'Be Sure of Your Facts!' was written by editor Jack Schiff, reflecting DC's Silver Age practice of embedding civics messages in anthology issues. No specific editorial anecdote about the issue's production has surfaced in available sources beyond the standard Superman-office pipeline under Mort Weisinger.
Trivia · 8 facts
- Cover date: July 1959; publication date: approximately May 1959 (DC Database).
- Three main stories: 'The MC of the Midnight Scare Theater!' (written by Robert Bernstein), 'Jimmy Olsen's Wedding!' (Robert Bernstein), and 'Olsen's Super-Supper!' (Robert Bernstein); cover and interior pencils by Curt Swan; inking by John Forte and John Giunta.
- 'Jimmy Olsen's Wedding!' is an early 'imaginary story' in which Jimmy, under dental anesthesia, dreams he marries Lucy Lane—one of the first such weddings for the couple, who had only debuted two issues prior in #36 (April 1959).
- The dream-wedding story establishes the core Lucy-Jimmy dramatic tension: Lucy demands Jimmy sever all ties with Superman as a condition of marriage, forcing Jimmy to give up his Daily Planet job and become a milkman and to suppress his signal watch.
- 'The MC of the Midnight Scare Theater!' features Jimmy as a substitute horror-show host whose 'victims' are revealed by the President of the United States to be operatives faking their deaths to become deep-cover spies—a Cold War backdrop typical of late-1950s DC storytelling.
- Two stories from this issue—'The MC of the Midnight Scare Theater!' and 'Jimmy Olsen's Wedding!'—were reprinted in 80 Page Giant #2 (September 1964), DC's landmark all-Jimmy-Olsen giant anthology.
- Curt Swan served as the series' main artist throughout its first decade, and his work in this issue is representative of the clean, expressive house style that anchored the Superman family of titles in the Silver Age.
- A public-service strip, 'Be Sure of Your Facts!' (written by Jack Schiff), and two Henry Boltinoff gag strips ('Jerry Jitterbug' and 'Little Pete') round out the issue, consistent with DC's Silver Age anthology format.
Cast · 6 characters
Full credits
Full plot ⚠ may contain spoilers
▸ Reveal full plot — may contain spoilers
Dr. Falke gives Jimmy a special pill to help him win the Planet eating contest so he can buy a new car and impress Lucy. Of course, the Dr. has an ulterior motive.
Plot details indexed by the Grand Comics Database (CC BY-SA).