Pep Comics #46
☆ Be the first to review + Add to your collection — Join freePep Comics #46 (February 1944) delivers the first appearance of Pop Tate, owner of Riverdale's Chocklit Shoppe — the teen hangout that would become one of the most recognizable settings in all of Archie Comics. The issue also lands squarely at the tipping point in the series' editorial identity: superhero stalwarts The Shield, The Hangman, and Captain Commando share pages with comedy stories, but the humor content is clearly winning, and The Hangman would bow out for good in the very next issue. Together, the debut of a cornerstone supporting character and the accelerating transition from Golden Age superhero anthology to the defining American teen-humor comic make this a genuine snapshot of comics history in the making.
In "Tales of a Safety Pin," Captain Barney Keel and Catfish Joe find themselves adrift on a sudden, unexpected lake after a dam breaks, turning their tugboat journey into an unplanned rescue mission for stranded animals. Written, drawn, and inked by Larry Harris, this 1944 adventure from Pep Comics #46 blends whimsy and urgency in a story that’s as quirky as its title suggests. The cover by Harry Sahle captures the moment with playful, dynamic flair.
In "Christmas Cheers," Archie finds himself with a $50 check from his grandfather and sets out to buy gifts for his friends, only to discover that the holiday spirit comes with a steep price—his budget vanishes faster than he expected. The story captures the charm and quiet chaos of a teenage holiday season, where generosity meets the realities of a tight pocket.
In "The Landgoing Tugboat," Captain Barney Keel and his gruff companion Catfish Joe find themselves in a strange new world when a sudden dam break floods the countryside, turning dry land into a vast, unexpected lake. With their trusty tugboat now navigating the new terrain, the duo set out to rescue stranded animals, discovering that even the most unlikely vessels can become lifelines in a crisis.
ComicBooks.com Value
Show all 15 grades ▾
More listings for this title
Read it digitally
Sell my copy
Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.
We Buy Collections ▸History
Published in February 1944 under the MLJ Magazines/Archie Publications imprint, the issue was edited by Harry Shorten, who had steered Pep Comics since issue #24 and oversaw the gradual shifting of editorial emphasis toward Archie's humor world. The Archie stories were scripted by Harry Sahle and Ed Goggin and illustrated by Sahle, with inks by Virginia Drury (credited as 'Ginger'), while the superhero material was handled largely by the prolific Otto Binder. The cover, also by Sahle, visualized the new comic hierarchy in miniature: The Shield — once the undisputed star of the series — has literally been reduced to a prop character helping Jughead build a gigantic Archie snowman.
Trivia · 8 facts
- First appearance of Pop Tate, owner of Pop's Chocklit Shoppe: in this debut he is depicted as a skinny, gray-haired older man with a mustache, and his establishment is called simply 'Tate's' — a very different look from his later standardized design.
- First appearance of Gabby, described in-story as the town blabbermouth, in the same 'Christmas Cheers' Archie story.
- 'Christmas Cheers' was scripted by Harry Sahle and Ed Goggin, penciled by Harry Sahle, and inked by Virginia Drury (credited as 'Ginger').
- The cover was illustrated by Harry Sahle and depicts The Shield and Jughead Jones constructing a giant snowman in Archie's likeness — a deliberate visual signal of Archie's ascendancy over the superhero characters.
- The Shield story 'Tales of a Safety Pin' and The Hangman story 'Dead Men's Eyes Tell Tales' were both scripted by Otto Binder, with the Hangman installment illustrated by Bob Fujitani (credited as 'B. Fuje').
- Captain Commando and the Boy Soldiers appear in 'The Ferryboat Admiral,' with the Boy Soldiers roster including Armand De Latour, Flatbush, Billy Grayson, and Percy.
- The Hangman's feature would end entirely with the very next issue, Pep Comics #47 (March 1944), making #46 his penultimate appearance in the series.
- The Archie stories from this issue were reprinted in Dark Horse's Archie Archives Vol. 3 (October 2011), a hardcover collection covering Pep Comics #46–50 and Archie Comics #7–10.
Cast · 19 characters
Full credits
Reprints
Reprinted in Black Hood #[nn] (1944), Capt. Commando Comics [Captain Commando and the Boy Soldiers] #[nn] (1945), Archie Archives #3 (2011), Archie 1000 Page Mega Comics Digest #[nn] (2014), Archie's Favorite Christmas Comics #[nn] (2014), Archie (Jumbo Comics) Double Digest #256 (2015), The Best of Archie Comics: 75 Years 75 Stories #[nn] (2015), Archie Archives #3 (2016)
Key issues in Pep Comics
Reviews
Reader reviews
No reader reviews yet.