52 #9
52 #9 holds the distinction of containing Batwoman's first appearance in costume — Kate Kane, perched silently on a rooftop, watching over Renee Montoya and the Question from above — making it the issue where the modern era's most significant openly lesbian superhero first stepped out of the shadows in her full red-and-black Alex Ross–designed suit. That single panel reverberated across mainstream media, with the character's LGBTQ+ identity drawing coverage from CNN, USA Today, and entertainment outlets at a moment when such representation at the 'highest profile' level was genuinely rare in superhero publishing. The issue also advances the Steel/Lex Luthor Everyman Project conflict and the stranded-in-space odyssey of Adam Strange, Starfire, and Animal Man, all while transitioning the backup feature from the 'History of the DCU' to a new Secret Origins strip — a structural milestone within the weekly series. Its place in Batwoman's publication history is complicated but real: the costume cameo here precedes her fully named, masked debut in issue #11, making #9 the bridge between Kate Kane's civilian introduction in #7 and her emergence as an active Gotham vigilante.
In "Dream of America," the world of superheroes collides with the mundane in a strikingly surreal snapshot of 2006, where the line between fantasy and advertising blurs. J. G. Jones crafts a cover that’s as sharp and layered as the story inside, turning everyday icons into something uncanny—Powerade, Dodge, the U.S. Army Reserve, and even Dungeons & Dragons all play their part in a world where the dream of being a hero feels just out of reach.
In "Dream of America," Steel stands defiant against Luthor as tensions rise over Natasha and the secret metahuman project, while the space castaways make a desperate break from Devilance. Meanwhile, the Question pushes Montoya deeper into a shadowy investigation, all watched closely by Batwoman.
ComicBooks.com Value
More listings for this title
Sell my copy
Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.
We Buy Collections ▸History
52 was an editorially ambitious undertaking conceived to fill the 'missing year' between the end of Infinite Crisis and DC's One Year Later line-wide jump, and it was the publisher's first weekly ongoing series since Action Comics Weekly (1988–1989). The four-writer room of Geoff Johns, Grant Morrison, Greg Rucka, and Mark Waid collaborated with layout artist Keith Giffen and series editor Stephen Wacker to produce a new issue every seven days for a full year — a logistical pressure cooker that directly shaped what appeared in each week's pages. The Batwoman costume cameo in issue #9 was itself a product of that pressure: according to CBR's behind-the-scenes reporting on the series, the rooftop silhouette was intended to remain a blank shadow teasing her eventual full reveal, but a miscommunication in the rush to meet the weekly deadline caused the figure to be fully rendered — inadvertently giving readers their first look at her Alex Ross–designed costume ahead of schedule. Greg Rucka, who wrote the Batwoman and Renee Montoya threads throughout 52, had already been developing a solo Batwoman project even before the character's first appearance, with DC having planned either an ongoing or miniseries prior to the weekly event.
Trivia · 8 facts
- First appearance of Kate Kane as Batwoman in costume: a single-panel rooftop cameo at the close of issue #9, the modern character's first visual presentation in her full red-and-black suit, preceding her full costumed debut in 52 #11.
- Kate Kane had appeared two weeks earlier as a civilian in 52 #7; #9 is the bridge issue where she is shown in the Batwoman identity for the first time, though her civilian identity is not confirmed in-costume until issue #11.
- Written by the four-writer collective of Geoff Johns, Grant Morrison, Greg Rucka, and Mark Waid, with breakdowns by Keith Giffen; interior art by penciler Shawn Moll and inker Tom Nguyen; cover by J.G. Jones and Alex Sinclair.
- Published July 5, 2006 (cover-dated September 2006), nine weeks into DC's year-long weekly series bridging Infinite Crisis and One Year Later.
- The main story, titled 'Dream of America,' runs three concurrent plot threads: Steel confronting Lex Luthor at a LexCorp Everyman Project party (where Natasha Irons fights her uncle with her newly granted powers); Adam Strange, Starfire, and Animal Man escaping the alien bounty hunter Devilance on a stranded planet; and the Question revealing to Renee Montoya that Intergang is targeting Gotham — with Batwoman watching from the rooftops as the issue closes.
- This issue debuts the new backup feature: a Secret Origins strip by Dan Jurgens and Norm Rapmund, replacing the 'History of the DCU' backup that had run since issue #2.
- The Batwoman costume reveal in #9 was reportedly unplanned in its specificity — a production miscommunication during the tight weekly schedule caused what was meant to be a vague silhouette to be rendered as a fully detailed figure, inadvertently giving readers their first clear look at the Alex Ross costume design ahead of schedule.
- The issue is reprinted in 52 Vol. 1 of the 2007 four-volume collected edition, 52 Volume One of the 2016 two-volume edition, and the 52 Omnibus (2012).
Full credits
Reprints
Reprinted in 52 #1 (2007), 52 #3 (2007), 52: The Covers #[nn] (2007), A História do Universo DC #[nn] (2009), 52 #1 (2012), The 52 Omnibus #[nn] (2013), 52 #1 (2016), DC Comics Graphic Novel Collection Premiumband #6 (2017), DC Comics Graphic Novel Collection Premiumband #7 (2017)
Key issues in 52
Variants (1)
Reviews
Reader reviews
No reader reviews yet.