A complete issue · 18 pages · 1890
Life — March 20, 1890
# "Two Views" - Life Magazine, March 20, 1890 This cartoon satirizes contrasting attitudes about horseback riding. The illustration shows two riders on horses beneath an arched bridge, with dialogue at the bottom: **She** (on the harder horse): "Don't you feel, such a morning as this, there's a great deal of good to be got out of this world?" **Pessimist** (on a hard horse): "Yes, a great deal more than there is to be got in it." The joke plays on the physical discomfort of riding—the euphemistic phrase "good to be got out of this world" is answered literally about the bodily pain of horseback riding. It's a gentle satire on philosophical pessimism, suggesting that discomfort paradoxically makes one appreciate escaping worldly troubles. The cartoon mocks both romantic idealization of outdoor activities and existential pessimism through physical humor.
# Page Analysis This page is **primarily advertisements** with one small cartoon illustration. The ads promote various products (carriages, perfume, jewelry, wine, exercise machines, and meat extract) typical of late 19th or early 20th-century commerce. The cartoon accompanying the **Noyes Bros. Exercising Machine** ad shows a figure using the device. The accompanying text humorously suggests the machine is gentler than typical severe exercise equipment of the era, safe enough for "ladies, men and children" to use without risk of overexertion. The joke appears to mock the period's obsession with mechanical exercise contraptions as a supposedly safe but still-effective fitness solution—appealing to Victorian sensibilities about proper, controlled exertion. The illustration itself is modest and the satire relatively mild.
# Analysis of Life Magazine Page (Volume XV, Number 377) This page contains several brief satirical items typical of Life's humor format: **Main image**: "A Regard for Appearances" depicts a conversation between a man and woman about divorce laws. The joke suggests that while Western divorce laws are loose, there's an unspoken social expectation that couples maintain appearances until their honeymoon ends—implying newlyweds shouldn't divorce too quickly, regardless of legal permission. **Minor items** include: - "Baby McKee" joke: A grandfather explains his small stature by referencing his late growth - "A Chestnut Steed": A brief quip about a white horse - "Self-Feeder" and "Polite Pedestrian": Short humorous anecdotes about everyday situations The overall tone reflects early-20th-century American middle-class social anxieties about propriety, divorce, and public conduct.
# Life Magazine, March 20, 1890 This page contains editorial commentary rather than a political cartoon. The masthead quote—"While there's Life there's Hope"—introduces discussions of contemporary social issues. The main content critiques **divorce law and remarriage practices**. The editors argue that contemporary society treats divorce too casually, allowing easily-divorced persons to remarry without sufficient social stigma. They propose a solution: **tiered marriage licenses based on character assessment**, with stricter requirements for those with "doubtful stability." The page also references a controversy involving **Colonel Ibsen** and a "Vassar girl" case (likely referring to Henrik Ibsen's influence on contemporary scandals), and discusses wealth's corrupting influence on character through literary references. The satirical point: American society's increasing permissiveness toward divorce reflects declining moral standards.
# Analysis of Life Magazine Page 165 This page contains two distinct pieces of satirical content: **"The Duke Gets the Last Word"** (top): A dialogue satirizing British-American relations, where a British Duke defends his borrowing of "legal-tender Americans" from the narrator's brother. The satire targets American social climbing and the British aristocracy's casual appropriation of American wealth and citizens. **"Generally Speaking—Women"** and "At the Reception" (bottom): A multi-panel cartoon sequence mocking social etiquette and gender relations. The scenario involves a woman (Barbara) introducing a gentleman (Mr. Floyd) at a reception, then complaining that he monopolized her car seat without courtesy. The humor centers on satirizing both male rudeness and female social complaints about propriety and age-related respect. The overall page satirizes class pretension and social hypocrisy in Gilded Age America.
# Analysis The page features an article titled "The Beginnings of a Scotch-Irish History" discussing a new publication by the Scotch-Irish Society of America, established at an 1889 Columbia, Tennessee congress. The accompanying illustration depicts a humorous scene of Scottish-Irish immigrants or their descendants, with one figure pointing upward (likely indicating aspiration or education) while others appear to be in modest circumstances, possibly workers or laborers. The caption below the cartoon contains dialect humor: "I jes' believe that 'B Feller is jes' as well off wid-out edducation" followed by a story about Bob Sawyer, a farmer's son who worked his way through school and later became successful, acquiring property through hard work and education. The satire critiques anti-education attitudes while celebrating Scotch-Irish industriousness and upward mobility through education.
# Analysis of This Life Magazine Page (March 20, 1890) The page is primarily **editorial content and advertisements** rather than political satire. The main visual element is a portrait of **Jeremiah Bowler, D.D., A.S.S., LL.D., Bishop of North Easter Ridge Island**, identified in the caption below the sketch. The editorial notes discuss theological and institutional matters (Methodist University, hospitals, museum policies) typical of a Christian-focused publication. The advertisements are characteristic of 1890s commercial pitches: lottery schemes, medical remedies, matrimonial services, and dubious investment opportunities. This appears to be from *The Gospel Advance*, a Christian endeavor journal, not Life's main satirical section. The content reflects late-19th-century American religious publishing rather than political commentary.
# Analysis of "The Perennial" This illustration depicts a formal social gathering—likely a ball or high-society event—showing elegantly dressed men and women in late 19th or early 20th-century attire. The caption reads: "What irresistible impulse is it that impels the shorter men..." (text cuts off). The satire appears to target social dynamics at formal events, specifically the behavior of shorter men in relation to taller women or prominent figures. The joke likely concerns how certain men are drawn to or compelled toward particular social interactions despite physical disparities or social positioning. The title "The Perennial" suggests this is a recurring, timeless social phenomenon being mocked. Without the complete caption, the specific critique remains partially unclear, but it's satirizing predictable behavioral patterns in upper-class social situations.
# Life Magazine Cartoon Analysis This cartoon illustrates "A Perplexing Puzzle" about social dancing etiquette. The caption asks: "Shorter men to dance with the longest girls, and vice versa?" The sketch depicts a formal dance or social gathering where men and women of notably different heights are paired together awkwardly. The central figure shows a short man with a taller woman, while other couples display similar mismatches, creating visual comedy. The satire mocks Victorian-era social conventions around proper dance partnering. The "puzzle" questions whether height-matching or height-contrast pairings were more appropriate—reflecting genuine anxieties about social protocol in genteel society. The exaggerated height disparities emphasize the absurdity of rigid etiquette rules governing even intimate social interactions like dancing.
# Analysis of Life Magazine Page 170 This page contains two distinct satirical pieces: **Top Cartoon ("She Lived to Learn"):** Two women sit conversing. The dialogue mocks gossip culture—Mr. Caustique jokes that Mrs. Gadd, having died, now knows all the neighborhood scandals she couldn't extract while living. The satire targets how death is treated as an afterlife opportunity to finally obtain social gossip, poking fun at both women's obsession with neighbors' secrets and the assumption that even death won't end curiosity about others' private affairs. **Bottom Section:** Includes a small architectural comparison showing a reverend's residence before/after his son entered college, followed by brief social commentary about opera ticket prices and complaints from Mrs. Cosmetique about dress descriptions at society events never crediting makeup manufacturers. The humor targets vanity and commercial self-interest.
# Analysis of Life Magazine Page 171 **Left side - "Too Much for Brer Rabbit":** A sequential comic strip showing a rabbit encountering a snake. The rabbit appears increasingly distressed across panels, suggesting the snake (likely representing a threat or predator) overwhelms even the clever rabbit character from African-American folklore. This satirizes situations where cunning alone cannot overcome superior force. **Right side - "Changed Times" photograph:** Shows a domestic scene with a father and son at a desk. The caption presents dialogue about business safety, suggesting changed social dynamics—the father trusts his young son with important matters during his absence, reflecting evolving parent-child relationships or generational shifts in responsibility. **Bottom - "Dyed" dialogue:** A brief exchange about a broken engagement, with a woman (Mabel) mentioning receiving romantic caramels—likely satirizing shallow romantic gestures.
# Analysis This page satirizes **romantic poetry and pretentious poets**. The two manuscript comparison exposes hypocrisy: The **First Manuscript** presents a poet railing against modern materialism and fashion, praising simple "Arcadian" living and claiming he wouldn't choose gold even if offered. The **Second Manuscript** immediately undercuts this—it's a bill from a tailor showing the same poet owes significant money ($322 total) for expensive clothing: dress vests, dinner coat, lounging jacket, and silk pajamas. The tailor demands immediate payment, noting the account "has been running too long already." The joke: the poet condemns wealth and fashion while spending lavishly on fine garments. His lofty ideals about simplicity clash hilariously with his actual consumer habits. The accompanying editorial about the Metropolitan Museum advocates opening it on Sundays so working-class New Yorkers can visit—a separate social critique about public access and class.