Life, 1908-01-30 · page 21 of 22
Life — January 30, 1908 — page 21: what you’re looking at
What you’re looking at
This page's central content is a satirical editorial commentary on a public dispute between Rev. Mr. Brady and the editor of *Collier's* magazine. **The Controversy:** Brady had circulated a letter to prominent men and women asking them to define what constitutes "a gentleman." *Collier's* obtained and republished the letter with mocking editorial commentary. Brady responded angrily, accusing the magazine of "newspaper blackguardism" and suggesting the letter was obtained unethically—which implicated three distinguished women as potential sources. **The Satire:** Life magazine titles this "The Literary Zoo," sarcastically framing the dispute as a spectacle of notable people behaving badly. The piece criticizes both sides: Brady for dragging innocent women into public controversy under the guise of seeking virtue, and *Collier's* for using insulting commentary. **The Point:** Life uses this petty squabble between religious and journalistic figures to mock how earnest pursuits of "Christian ideals" and editorial sensationalism descend into undignified personal attacks—suggesting the modern press and public figures lack basic decorum.
📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)
Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.
‘LIFE: Rare Plants and Flowers Dards in great variety Prompt reliable service Forty-fourth St. and Madison Ave. 114 West 72d St.. N. Y. CLARK’S K’S CRUISE OF THE “ ARABIC” 16,000 tons, fine, arge, unusually steady. To THE ORIENT February 6 to April 17, 1908 costing only $400.00 and up, in- cluding shore excursions. SPECIAL FEATURES: Madeira, Cadi Algiers, Malta, 19 days in Egypt and the Hol Constantinople, Athens, Rome, the Riviera, etc. 40 TOURS TO EUROPE Most comprehensive and attractive ever offered F.C. CLARK, Times Building, New York SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY Shortest route through most at- tractive cities and stopover points to Resorts of the Carolinas and Florida. For Booklets address, Seventy d Seville, W.E. CONKLYN, 1183 Broadway, New York BERMUDA “THE IDEAL WINTER RESORT” sy as Nours from New York ty frequent steamers of Quebec 8. 8: Co (a9 be Y=) Outdoor ite, Vac oIf, Sea Tiath. ee Gicaeclightes toughest the mister’ The wellaows PRINCESS HOTEL 68x OPEN HOWE & TWOROGER, Mgrs., Hamilton, Bermuda aD SRIDGE Registered at Pat. Na handsome, reproduction of (8 Werke. ilue, FOR TOURS AND CRUISES TO THE OR TO ORIENT v2 WEST INDIES, ITALY OR EGYPT See our illustrated book of information Hamburg-American Line New York Boston St. Louis San Francisco Chicago Philadelphia Seantte Lier The Literary’ Zoo 2D exhibit our Lord as the ideal gentleman of humanity” Realizing from experience that thirty heads are better than one, he addressed a circular letter to. a number of eminent men and women (all ideal in their respective departments of activity), asking their collaboration in solving the oft-pro- pounded question, “What is a ‘gentle- man’?” The editor of Collier’s saw a copy of this letter, and reproduced it with certain disparaging remarks on its author. The printing of a circular letter of this specific nature was not, in our opinion, a violation of privacy; but the question of taste involved in its publication was com- plicated by the editor's insulting comment, and by the peculiar sense of humor which led him to suggest a supplementary list of collaborators somewhat unhappy in the juxtaposition of honored names with notorious ones. The Rev. Mr. Brady replied with a communication in which “newspaper blackguardism” and ‘“scoundrelly con- duct” are among the characterizations of the editor’s action. He believes that unless the letter (addressed ‘My Dear Madam:”) was obtained surreptitiously, it fastens “a y ugly action” on one of three distin- guished ladies whom Mr. Brady does not hesitate to drag into publicity. One of these ladies has explained her innocence in the matter, and has expressed her opinion of Mr. Brady’s quest as “irreverent,” and her regret that his gréat sense of delicacy did not carry him a bit further in his search for a culprit. The other two, at last accounts, were still under suspicion. It will be seen that the pursuit of Christian ideals (even in the season of good- will to men) is attended with difficulties, and that a modern Diogenes looking for a gentleman is apt to run up against an editor looking for a picturesque topic. We regret to sec that the personalities no longer considered good form by the daily press have been adopted in quarters where re- flection has time to cool. Meanwhile, our cry is for a socially ethical Daniel come to judgment. In the delicately balanced case of Brady vs. Collier’s, or vice versa, we feel ourselves incompetent to deliver the award. HEN the foreign missionary had conclu- ded his talk, he made the usual appeal for contributions, however small. Coming up to the. platform with several others, a small boy mounted to the level of the lecturer and hastening toward him, said, “Please, sir, I was very much interested in your lecture, and —and"— “Go on, my little man,” said the mission- ary, encouragingly. “You want to help in the good work? “Not exactly, sir,” said the boy. ‘What I want to know is, have you any foreign stamps you don't want?”—Argonaut. ‘The Trans-Siberian train de luxe is a new thing in Round the World Tours. of exclusive party. EEL AIPDIPPDOID www) ” pmimiamaiat at nas eee ITs : Its QUALITY QUALITY UNEQUALED UNEQUALED EXCELLENCE, EXCELLENCE UNSURPASSED UNSURPASSED LIQUEUR Peres Chartreux —GREEN AND YELLOW— famous cordial, now made at Tarragona, was for centuries distilled by the sian Monks (Péres Charlreux), at the Monastery of La Grande Chartreuse, France, and known throughout the world as Char- treuse. The above cut represents the bottle and label employed in the putting up of the article since the Monks’ ex pasion {rom France, and it is now known as Liqueur Peres Char- treux (the Monks, however, still retain the right to use the old botile and label as well), distilled by the same order of Monks, who have securely warded the secret of its manufacture for undreds of years, taking it with them at the time they Ieft the Monastery of La Grande Chartr alone possess this delicious with the name cs Charireux) cir expulsion from France is at made by them at Tarra- ¢ Hroadway. New Vork, N.Y. ‘Agents for Unit CS SUS St Ot Le Lf ina PEELE ERE EE EF RR THE KIRKWOOD on Camden Heights SOUTH CAROLINA |An Ideal Winter Climate T. EDMUND KRUMBHOLZ FOR ABSOLUTE SECURITY with unusual interest rates, try the TAX BONDS of the Great Central West. We are selling $100, $250, $500 and $1,000 School. City, County District Bonds— * Sure as taxes themsely Netting 5% to 6% Write for Booklet D, a concise “Argument for Tax Bonds." and get your name on our mailing list. Customers throughout 26 states; we can give you near-by references, WRITE TO-DAY 28 Warde! Macon, Mo. comicbooks.com