Tim Holt #25
☆ Be the first to review + Add to your collection — Join freeTim Holt #25 marks the debut of Black Phantom, one of the most fully realized female characters to emerge from the Golden Age western comics boom — introduced not as a sidekick or romantic foil but as the lead antagonist of her own self-contained story. Her trajectory from masked train-robbing outlaw to eventual crime-fighting partner of Red Mask gave the Tim Holt series a moral complexity unusual for the genre, drawing inevitable comparisons to the Catwoman–Batman dynamic in superhero comics. The issue represents a deliberate creative pivot for the title: as star Tim Holt's Hollywood career faded, Magazine Enterprises doubled down on costumed-villain characters to sustain reader interest, and Black Phantom proved durable enough to carry her own solo one-shot and to outlast the Tim Holt name itself when the series was retitled Red Mask. For collectors and historians, it stands as a clear example of how western comics of the early 1950s were quietly experimenting with morally ambiguous female leads years before the broader industry caught up.
Tim Holt battles the mysterious villain Redmask and his ally the Black Phantom, who have been terrorizing the Arizona territories with a blacksnake whip and various weapons. After a confrontation at a stagecoach, Tim pursues them and eventually confronts Redmask, who demonstrates his deadly accuracy with a whip and thrown knife before being defeated. The story concludes with Tim taking Redmask into custody as a hardened Texas gunman.
Deputy Sheriff Tim Holt—riding as the masked Redmask—discovers that Jicilla, a seemingly innocent singer, has a twin sister: the notorious Black Phantom, a ruthless outlaw who strikes at stagecoaches and trains across the Arizona territory. When Chito, Tim's sidekick, stumbles upon the Black Phantom's true identity, he's captured and held over the treacherous Death Well, a natural whirlpool that devours whatever falls into it, forcing Redmask into a desperate fight against the Black Phantom's crew and her brutal enforcer, the Beast. With danger closing in from all sides and Chito's life hanging by a thread, Redmask must use every ounce of courage and cunning to survive the deadly trap that's been set for him.
When young Ed Conoton becomes the target of Lute Phipps' hired Texas gunslinger, Deputy Sheriff Tim Holt finds himself powerless to stop the killing—but Redmask, Holt's masked alter ego, has another plan. Working undercover as Phipps' own hired gun, Redmask rounds up the ranchers and orchestrates a clever trap to turn the tables on the corrupt cattle baron and his army of hired guns. It's a Western tale of deception and justice where one masked man outsmarts a whole crew of hardcases to save a town from tyranny.
ComicBooks.com Value
Show all 14 grades ▾
This exact issue on ebay
Sell my copy
Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.
We Buy Collections ▸History
Frank Bolle, who illustrated every single Tim Holt and Red Mask episode throughout the title's entire run, both drew and covered this issue, with Dick Ayers contributing the Ghost Rider backup. The character was introduced as part of a conscious editorial strategy by Magazine Enterprises: by Tim Holt #20 the publisher had already given the actor-based hero a masked alter ego called Red Mask, and issue #25 continued that push toward costumed-character storytelling by adding a foil worthy of the new direction. There is documented uncertainty among historians about whether the scripts for this era of the series were written by Gardner Fox or editor Raymond C. Krank — a question that remains unresolved in the secondary literature.
Trivia · 8 facts
- First appearance of Black Phantom (real name Helena), a masked female outlaw and train robber, in the lead story 'Redmask and the Black Phantom,' drawn and covered by Frank Bolle.
- The issue also introduces Helena's twin sister (variously spelled 'Jicilla' or 'Jicarilla' across sources), a saloon singer romantically linked to Tim Holt's sidekick Chito — a plot device central to the debut story.
- Black Phantom's first appearance casts her as a villain: she orders Chito killed after he accidentally discovers her secret identity; Tim Holt intervenes as Red Mask, and Helena escapes by leaping from a cliff, seemingly to her death.
- The issue contains multiple stories: the lead Red Mask/Black Phantom story, 'Death to the Deputy,' 'A Trap for the Ghost Rider,' 'The Bullet,' and 'Guns of the Killer!' — with Dick Ayers providing art for the Ghost Rider backup.
- Black Phantom went on to appear in Tim Holt #25–41, earned her own solo one-shot (Black Phantom #1, Magazine Enterprises, 1954, with scripts by Gardner Fox), and continued through the retitled Red Mask series (#42–54).
- Tim Holt himself is depicted in his dual identity as Deputy Sheriff Tim Holt and the masked hero Red Mask, a costumed persona he had first adopted in Tim Holt #20 (1950).
- The character entered the public domain and has since been reprinted by AC Comics (in the Black Phantom miniseries, 1989–1990, and Best of the West anthology) and by Gwandanaland Comics, keeping her accessible to modern readers.
- Magazine Enterprises, the publisher, operated from 1943 to 1958 and is best remembered for the Tim Holt and Durango Kid titles; the company folded in the wake of the Comics Code Authority, and the Tim Holt/Red Mask run concluded in 1957–1958.
Cast · 4 characters
Full credits
Reprints
Reprinted in Best of the West #4 (1952), All Star Adventure Comic #33 (1965), Black Phantom #1 (1989), Best of the West #47 (2005), Lurid Little Nightmare Makers #1 (2014), Tim Holt Western Adventures #29
Key issues in Tim Holt
Reviews
Reader reviews
No reader reviews yet.