Batgirl #1
Batgirl #1 (2011) marks Barbara Gordon's return to the Batgirl identity after more than two decades away from the role — she had operated as the wheelchair-using information broker Oracle since Batman: The Killing Joke (1988) disabled her, and the New 52 relaunch was the first time DC's main continuity restored her to the cowl. The issue is doubly significant because it contains the debut appearance of Alysia Yeoh, Barbara's new roommate, who would later be recognized as the first major transgender character written in a contemporary context in a mainstream American comic book. Writer Gail Simone chose not to hand-wave the Killing Joke's trauma away: Barbara still experiences PTSD, still drives a wheelchair-accessible van, and still carries profound guilt about her recovery — a storytelling choice that made the relaunch feel psychologically grounded rather than a simple continuity erasure. Because it sits at the intersection of a landmark publishing event, a character resurrection of enormous cultural weight, and a quiet trans-representation milestone, the issue occupies an unusually dense position in modern DC history.
ComicBooks.com Value
Show all 13 grades ▾
More listings for this title
Read it digitally
Sell my copy
Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.
We Buy Collections ▸History
The series was born out of DC's September 2011 'New 52' line-wide relaunch, in which all 52 ongoing titles reset to #1 following the conclusion of the Flashpoint crossover event. DC editorial assigned Gail Simone — who had spent years defining Barbara Gordon's voice through her celebrated Birds of Prey run — to write the title, a pairing that was widely seen as the most logical creative choice for handling the controversial restoration of Barbara's mobility. Indonesian penciller Ardian Syaf, who had recently completed a two-year exclusive contract with DC, was brought on to design the New 52 look for Batgirl and served as the series' primary artist for its first year; Vicente Cifuentes inked, Ulises Arreola Palomera colored, and Adam Hughes provided the cover. Simone's tenure on the book would itself become a footnote in editorial history when she was abruptly fired in December 2012 by incoming editor Brian Cunningham, then reinstated days later after substantial fan backlash — an episode that underscored how protective readers had become of her stewardship of the character.
Trivia · 8 facts
- Published September 7, 2011 (cover-dated November 2011) as part of DC's New 52 line-wide relaunch; the story is titled 'Shattered.'
- Written by Gail Simone; pencils by Ardian Syaf; inks by Vicente Cifuentes; colors by Ulises Arreola Palomera; cover by Adam Hughes.
- Marks the in-continuity return of Barbara Gordon as Batgirl after roughly 23 years (real-world time) during which she had been depicted as the paraplegic Oracle, a role she held from 1989 onward following the events of Batman: The Killing Joke.
- First appearance of The Mirror, the debut villain of the arc, a former soldier who targets survivors of 'miraculous' near-death events because his own family perished while he survived.
- First appearance of Alysia Yeoh — unnamed in this issue but later revealed to be a transgender woman of Singaporean descent — who becomes Barbara's roommate; she would go on to be recognized as the first major trans character written in a contemporary context in mainstream American comics.
- In the New 52 continuity, Barbara's paralysis is compressed to three years and her recovery is described as a near-miraculous event rather than an explicitly technological fix; the issue deliberately withholds detailed explanation, foregrounding her lingering PTSD and survivor's guilt instead.
- The mysterious figure Pandora — a character who appeared silently in every single New 52 #1 issue as a narrative thread tying the relaunch together — makes a background cameo, visible as a reflection in a hospital window.
- The first arc (issues #1–6, 'The Darkest Reflection') was collected in a trade paperback that became a New York Times Best Seller; the issue itself went to at least a third printing, reflecting substantial reader demand at launch.
Full credits
Reprints
Reprinted in DC Comics: The New 52 #[nn] (2012), Batman Saga #1 (2012), Batgirl #1 (2012), Batgirl #1 (2012), Batgirl #1 (2012), Batgirl #1 (2013), Batman Giant #8 (2019)
Variants (3)
Reviews
Reader reviews
No reader reviews yet.