comicbooks.com Join Free
All Star Western #95 cover
Cover: Gil Kane & Joe Giella

All Star Western #95

Jun 1957 · DC · 0.10 USD
☆ Be the first to review + Add to your collection — Join free

In "The Riddle of the Reward Robber!", Johnny Thunder rides shotgun on a stagecoach through the dusty plains, only to be ambushed by the Gopher Gang. When the Sheriff is wounded and his son John Tane—secretly Johnny Thunder—steps in to help, a sudden twist leaves the Sheriff questioning his son’s true identity, even as a falling sign knocks John out cold. Written by Robert Kanigher and illustrated with sharp, dynamic flair by Gil Kane—both interior and cover—this 1957 DC classic captures a moment of suspense and identity in the heart of the Western frontier.

Contains 5 stories
The Riddle of the Reward Robber!
6 pp · Western-Frontier
Trigger Twins

In "The Riddle of the Reward Robber!" from All Star Western #95, the elusive Floyd Burke—known for stealing only the amount of his own bounty—draws a massive $20,000 reward, setting off a wild chase. When the Twins, posing as sheriffs, take on the mission, chaos follows: Walt is knocked out by a grizzly bear, and only by teaming up can they fend off the beast and bring Burke to justice. Yet even as they succeed, Walt can’t help but dream of the day his brother Jo, the real hero, earns the town’s praise.

Untitled Humor story
1 pp · Humor, Western-Frontier
Attack of the Gopher Gang!
5.67 pp · Western-Frontier
Johnny Thunder

In "Attack of the Gopher Gang!" from All Star Western #95, Johnny Thunder rides shotgun on a stagecoach across the frontier plains, only to be ambushed by the sudden, burrowing Gopher Gang. When the Sheriff is wounded and his son John Tane—secretly Johnny Thunder—steps in to defend him, the truth begins to stir in the old man’s mind, even as a falling sign knocks John Tane unconscious and the mystery remains unsolved.

The Siege of Fort Desolation!
6 pp · Western-Frontier

In "The Siege of Fort Desolation!" from All Star Western #95, Lt. Foley faces a desperate stand as Comanche forces surround Fort Desolation. With a clever ruse and a mysterious scout named Tall-As-A-Hill, he sets a trap that turns the tide in a sudden, chaotic battle. The story unfolds with tense strategy and swift action, leaving the fate of the fort—and Tall-As-A-Hill’s true allegiance—hanging in the balance.

Secret of the Silent Indians!
6 pp · Western-Frontier

In "Secret of the Silent Indians!" from All Star Western #95, a year-long silence among the Aranki Indians tests their faith when a sudden attack threatens their village—only to be answered by the unspoken courage of Strong Bow, whose actions during the sacred tongue-fast prove vital. The story unfolds with quiet tension, as the tribe’s silence becomes both a trial and a lifeline, and Strong Bow must rise to protect them through instinct, skill, and a signal horn that breaks the stillness.

ComicBooks.com Value

Our Model is In Beta
Raw (VG) $28
CGC 9.0 · 1 in census $387*
CGC 8.5 none in existence
CGC 8.0 none in existence
CGC 7.5 none in existence
CGC 7.0 none in existence
CGC 6.5 · 1 in census $114*
Show all 11 grades
CGC 6.0 none in existence
CGC 5.5 none in existence
CGC 5.0 none in existence
CGC 4.5 none in existence
CGC 4.0 · 1 in census $63*
* estimate — limited direct-sales data at this grade
Our model’s value — refined as new sales data arrives · CGC census counts shown where available

This exact issue on

Raw / ungraded $40 1 listing
Verified matches for All Star Western #95 · eBay asking prices, seen 29 days ago

Sell my copy

Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.

We Buy Collections ▸
Fast, fair offers · we handle grading & shipping

Full credits

artist, inker Gil Kane
cover pencils Gil Kane
cover inks Joe Giella

Reprints

↩ Reprints Tomahawk #14 (1952)

Reprinted in Seriemagasinet #10/1958 (1958), Seriemagasinet #11/1958 (1958), Seriemagasinet #1/1959 (1958), Tomahawk #131 (1970)

Reviews

Reader reviews

No reader reviews yet.