All Star Superman #9

Frank Quitely's cover for this Eisner Award-winning series delivers an instantly arresting image: a visibly weakened Superman kneeling on the ground while a concerned woman steadies him from behind, as two imposing figures in yellow-and-purple costumes bearing a distinctive triangular emblem loom over them. The title "Curse of the Replacement Supermen" promises exactly the kind of grand, high-concept storytelling that Grant Morrison and Quitely made their hallmark on All Star Superman. It's a quietly unsettling composition — the Man of Steel brought low, attended by strangers — that makes you want to turn the page immediately.