comicbooks.com Join Free
All-Star Comics #3 cover
Cover: E. E. Hibbard

All-Star Comics #3

Dec 1940 · DC · 0.10 USD
☆ Be the first to review + Add to your collection — Join free
About this Issue

All-Star Comics #3 is the foundational document of the superhero team genre — the first comic book in history to unite multiple costumed heroes under a single organizational banner. Because several of its eight founding members (the Atom, Flash, Green Lantern, and Hawkman) were published by All-American Publications while others belonged to National Comics, the issue also qualifies as comics' first inter-company crossover title, a structural achievement that prefigured every shared universe to follow. The storytelling device it introduced — a framing sequence in which heroes gather and recount individual adventures — set an ensemble template that shaped the Justice League, the Avengers, and virtually every major superhero team that came after. Its cultural shadow is enormous: the Justice Society of America born here became the spiritual ancestor of the entire team-book genre that now dominates mainstream comics and superhero cinema.

Contains 12 stories
The First Meeting of the Justice Society of America, Introduction
4 pp · Superhero
Justice Society of America [Doctor Fate [Kent Nelson]The Hourman [Rex Tyler]The Sandman [Wesley Dodds]The Flash [Jay Garrick]Green Lantern [Alan Scott]Hawkman [Carter Hall]The Spectre [Jim Corrigan]The Atom [Al Pratt]] (introduction)Johnny ThunderThe Thunderbolt [Archibald] (cameo)
The First Meeting of the Justice Society of America, Chapter 1
7 pp · Superhero
The Flash [Jay Garrick]Mary RogersTim Rogers (Mary's father)Johnny Thunder (cameo)Hawkman (cameo)Nancy K sailors [Burly Billyrest unnamed] (villains)

In a tale from the early days of superheroics, the Flash recounts the legend of the sunken galleon *Sancta Joanna*, lost in 1567 with a fortune in Aztec gold—now sought by Tim Rogers’s father, whose salvage efforts are threatened by a ruthless rival crew. With the Flash stepping in to protect the dig, justice is served before the tale turns to Hawkman’s own story of fire-dwellers from ancient times.

The First Meeting of the Justice Society of America, Chapter 2: The Men Who Could Live in Fire
7 pp · Superhero
Hawkman [Carter Hall]Shiera SandersJohnny Thunder (cameo)The Spectre [Jim Corrigan] (cameo)Mazda (villain, leader of the Volcano People, a scientist, death)The Volcano People (villains, all die)a dying native (villain, death)

In "The First Meeting of the Justice Society of America, Chapter 2: The Men Who Could Live in Fire," Shiera and Carter race to uncover the secrets of the Krakatoa volcano, only to face a deadly warning and a terrifying encounter with fire-walking beings from within the crater. As they’re captured and sentenced to die by the mysterious Mazda, Hawkman’s courage and quick thinking lead to a daring escape—just before the volcano erupts. The Spectre then steps forward to share his own tale.

The First Meeting of the Justice Society of America, Chapter 3
6.5 pp · Superhero
The Spectre [Jim Corrigan]unnamed night watchman (death)unnamed Police ChiefJohnny Thunder (cameo)The Hour-Man [Rex Tyler] (cameo)Oom (villain, death)dragon (villain, death)

In "The First Meeting of the Justice Society of America, Chapter 3," the Ghostly Guardian faces off against Oom, a lunar creature born from the dark side of the Moon, after a string of full-moon murders plague the city. When the two clash, they strike a desperate bargain: the one who brings the Red Moon Stone of Yzgartyl to Earth will stay, while the other is banished. Though Oom claims the stone first, the Spectre outwits him, trapping the creature in stone forever. As the dust settles, Hour-Man steps forward to share his own story.

The First Meeting of the Justice Society of America, Chapter 4
5.5 pp · Superhero
The Hour-Man [Rex Tyler]Rex Tyler's unnamed bossRegina Paige (Tyler's bosses' niece)Mr. Durant (villain)group of phony Hour-Men (villains)

In this 1940 installment from All-Star Comics #3, Rex Tyler, now the Hour-Man, attends a costume party with his niece—only to find himself outmatched by a room full of impostors wearing the same iconic suit. As the real Hour-Man uncovers a theft orchestrated by a fake Diamond Collection and a crooked host, he takes down the gang and exposes the mastermind behind the scheme. With the truth revealed, the spotlight shifts to the Sandman, who’s about to take the stage.

The First Meeting of the Justice Society of America, Interlude
1 pp · Superhero
Justice Society of America [The Hour-Man [Rex Tyler]The Sandman [Wesley Dodds]The Flash [Jay Garrick]]Johnny ThunderThe Red Tornado [Ma Hunkle]

In a quiet moment between tales, the Red Tornado steps into the room, having listened to the Justice Society’s gathering, then quietly departs—leaving behind her red pants, now with a noticeable hole, as a curious afterthought.

The First Meeting of the Justice Society of America, Chapter 5
6 pp · Superhero
The Sandman [Wesley Dodds]Dian BelmontJohnny Thunder (cameo)Dr. Fate [Kent Nelson] (cameo)Dr. Faversham (villain)

In the countryside, Wes and Dian witness the sudden collapse of a giant man, setting off a chain of strange discoveries. When reports surface of mysterious bags containing human remains, the Sandman tracks the clues to Dr. Faversham’s secluded home, where he uncovers a sinister experiment involving a secret formula injected into victims’ pituitary glands. As the Sandman confronts the doctor, the mystery deepens—only to be handed off to Dr. Fate, who promises to continue the tale.

The First Meeting of the Justice Society of America, Chapter 6
6 pp · Superhero
Dr. Fate [Kent Nelson]Inza CramerJohnny Thunder (cameo)The Atom [Al Pratt] (cameo)Egyptian Princessantique store ownera wizard (villain, death)dead phantoms (villains)Three Witches of Endor (villains, cameo)

Inza visits an antique store where a mysterious woman leaves her a box before vanishing—only for it to unleash the drug Chevergris and send her into unconsciousness. Dr. Fate steps in, guiding her through a haunting encounter with phantoms in the Moors, where dark magic threatens to claim her. As he confronts the sorcerer behind the ancient book of resurrection, fate itself hangs in the balance.

The First Meeting of the Justice Society of America, Chapter 7
6 pp · Superhero
The Atom [Al Pratt]Mary JamesJohnny Thunder (cameo)The Boss (villain)The Brooklyn Murder Trust (villains, a gang of crooks)

In this 1940 tale from All-Star Comics #3, geology student Al stumbles upon a gang of criminals in Brooklyn disguising themselves as soldiers, setting up a heist that may involve a stolen government gold cache. When he tries to intervene, he’s knocked out—only to be found by Mary, who nearly uncovers his secret. As he regains consciousness and spots the armored truck again, he springs into action. Johnny then takes the floor, signaling it’s time for another story to unfold.

The First Meeting of the Justice Society of America, Interlude
1 pp · Superhero
Justice Society of America [Green Lantern [Alan Scott]The Flash [Jay Garrick]Doctor Fate [Kent Nelson]The Spectre [Jim Corrigan]The Hour-Man [Rex Tyler]The Sandman [Wesley Dodds]Hawkman [Carter Hall]]Johnny Thunderunnamed messenger boy
The First Meeting of the Justice Society of America, Chapter 8
7 pp · Superhero
Green Lantern [Alan Scott]Police Commissioner MasonPaul Pryer (news reporter)Irene Millerunnamed City MayorJohnny Thunder (cameo)un-named judgeCommissioner Lacy (villain)Lacy's thugs ["Ape"rest unnamed] (villains)

In the shadowed streets of 1940s America, a corrupt police commissioner’s downfall sparks a wave of criminal activity that no one can stop—until Green Lantern uncovers the truth behind the new Commissioner Lacy’s rise. With the help of reporter Paul Pryor, he races to expose a conspiracy that’s rewriting justice from within, but when the stakes turn deadly, even the mightiest hero may not survive the night.

The First Meeting of the Justice Society of America, Conclusion
1 pp · Superhero
Justice Society of America [Green Lantern [Alan Scott]The Flash [Jay Garrick]Dr. Fate [Kent Nelson]The Hour Man [Rex Tyler]The Sandman [Wesley Dodds]The Atom [Al Pratt]The Spectre [Jim Corrigan]Hawkman [Carter Hall]]Johnny Thunder

In the final pages of All-Star Comics #3, the Justice Society of America gathers as the Flash returns from Washington, where he’s been briefing the government. With the team now aware of a scheduled meeting with the FBI Chief for the coming Tuesday, they unanimously agree to travel to Washington—setting the stage for what comes next.

ComicBooks.com Value

Our Model is In Beta
Raw (Good) $3,067
CGC 9.6 · 1 in census $391,038*
CGC 9.4 · 1 in census $259,793*
CGC 9.2 none in existence
CGC 9.0 none in existence
CGC 8.5 · 2 in census $90,847*
CGC 8.0 · 1 in census $63,367*
Show all 21 grades
CGC 7.5 $29,740*
CGC 7.0 · 3 in census $29,740*
CGC 6.5 · 5 in census $29,740*
CGC 6.0 · 5 in census $27,730*
CGC 5.5 · 6 in census $25,924
CGC 5.0 · 2 in census $24,509*
CGC 4.5 · 2 in census $20,926*
CGC 4.0 · 4 in census $18,174
CGC 3.5 · 5 in census $17,619*
CGC 3.0 · 5 in census $13,356
CGC 2.5 none in existence
CGC 2.0 · 4 in census $9,888*
CGC 1.5 · 5 in census $7,192
CGC 1.0 · 6 in census $4,703
CGC 0.5 · 8 in census $4,703
* estimate — limited direct-sales data at this grade
Our model’s value — refined as new sales data arrives · CGC census counts shown where available

This exact issue on

CGC 9.8 $247 1 listing CGC 8 $26,000 1 listing CBCS 7.5 $19,750 1 listing
Raw — NM $9.95–$14.99 3 listings
Raw — VF $24.97 1 listing
Raw / ungraded $9.99–$1,990 4 listings
Verified matches for All-Star Comics #3 · eBay asking prices, seen 29 days ago

Sell my copy

Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.

We Buy Collections ▸
Fast, fair offers · we handle grading & shipping

History

All-Star Comics had launched in the summer of 1940 as a straightforward anthology, starring heroes from two sister publishers — All-American Publications and National Comics — in completely separate stories with no interaction. Editor Sheldon Mayer and writer Gardner Fox recognized that the title's 'greatest hits' premise had a logical next step: what if those heroes actually met and talked to one another? Fox scripted the framing narrative that brought eight champions together in a hotel meeting room, with the uninvited Johnny Thunder accidentally accelerating the gathering through his magic Thunderbolt. The cover of the issue — and much of the interior art — was the work of Everett E. Hibbard, while the individual chapter segments were illustrated by a rotating pool of Golden Age artists including Sheldon Moldoff, Bernard Baily, Howard Sherman, and Martin Nodell, reflecting the multi-studio origins of the characters themselves.

Trivia · 8 facts

  • First appearance and origin of the Justice Society of America (JSA) — the first superhero team in comic book history — with a cover date of Winter 1940–1941, published November 22, 1940.
  • Charter membership consisted of eight heroes: Doctor Fate, Hourman, the Spectre, Sandman, the Atom, the Flash (Jay Garrick), Green Lantern (Alan Scott), and Hawkman.
  • Written by Gardner Fox and edited by Sheldon Mayer; the framing sequence and cover art were by Everett E. Hibbard, with interior chapter art contributed by Sheldon Moldoff, Bernard Baily, Howard Sherman, Martin Nodell, and others.
  • Because the Flash, Atom, Green Lantern, and Hawkman were All-American Publications characters while the Spectre, Sandman, Hourman, and Doctor Fate were National Comics characters, this is widely cited as the first inter-company superhero crossover title in comics history.
  • Superman and Batman are referenced in the issue's text as having been invited to the founding meeting but absent due to other duties; both were classified as 'honorary members' since they already headlined their own titles — an in-house editorial rule that was formalized in print with All-Star Comics #5.
  • The original Red Tornado (Ma Hunkel) also appears in the issue, arriving at — then deciding against joining — the meeting, giving her a unique cameo association with the JSA's very first gathering.
  • The issue has been reprinted multiple times: in Famous First Edition #F-7 (1975), All-Star Comics Archives Vol. 1 (1992), DC's Millennium Edition (June 2000), a Facsimile Edition (2024), and DC Finest: Justice Society of America: For America and Democracy (2024).
  • The JSA concept born here directly inspired DC's Silver Age Justice League of America (debuting in The Brave and the Bold #28, 1960), which Gardner Fox also scripted, closing a creative loop between the genre's founding text and its Silver Age reinvention.

Full credits

artist, inker, letterer Howard Sherman
artist, inker E. E. Hibbard
cover pencils, inks E. E. Hibbard

Reprints

Reprinted in Action Comics #32 (1941), Adventure Comics #58 (1941), Detective Comics #47 (1941), Comic Reprints #[3] (1974), Famous First Edition #F-7 (1975), America vs. the Justice Society #2 (1985), All Star Comics Archives #1 (1992), Millennium Edition: All Star Comics No. 3 #[Chromium Edition] (2000), Millennium Edition: All Star Comics No. 3 #[nn] (2000), Coleção DC 75 Anos #1 (2010), L'histoire des super-héros #[nn] (2016), DC Comics Graphic Novel Collection #91 (2016), All-Star Comics 3 (Facsimile Edition) #[nn] (2024), DC Finest: Justice Society of America: For America and Democracy #[nn] (2025)

Key issues in All-Star Comics

Variants (1)

Reviews

Reader reviews

No reader reviews yet.