ComicBooks.com Register / Loginit's free!

Life, 1928-08-16 · page 31 of 48

Life — August 16, 1928 — page 31: what you’re looking at

📖 Open the full issue in the page-flip reader →
Life — August 16, 1928 — page 31: Life, 1928-08-16

What you’re looking at

This *Life* magazine page critiques the early "talkie" era's desperate attempts to salvage weak films by adding sound effects. The central complaint: Hollywood studios were taking poorly-performing silent movies and artificially adding synchronized sound—roaring walruses, sea-gulls, etc.—hoping noise would mask bad storytelling. The critic praises Robert Benchley's comedic sound shorts as genuinely funny, contrasting them with established comedians who flop in talkies. The Shakespeare quote ("a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing") perfectly captures the satire: adding sound without substance is worthless. The cartoons humorously illustrate this excess. The bottom cartoon shows a fisherman excitedly catching a fish—visual humor that needs no added sound, implying that good comedy works silently. The page argues the transition to sound should enhance good material, not rescue bad films with artificial effects.

📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)

Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.

rs LIFE “Lost in the Arctic,” and the Metro- Goldwyn officials had on hand a semi- dramatic production entitled, “White Shadows in the South Seas.” Both of these pictures were interesting in their original form, and needed no mechanical accessories, Neither of them, however, appeared to possess any great degree of box-office pull- ing power, so both were dragged into the laboratory and subjected to the brutal process of “synchronization.” With the result that we see some fine photography in each, and hear, at the same time, the obviously artificial roaring of walruses, it is much better, as to both sounds and | glecping of turtles, cawing of sea-gulls, pictures. and squealing and cooing of nude South Mr. Benchley seems to be all set now |Sea maidens as they plunge .into the as a vocal film star, but I hope the money | rattling surf. y y and fame won't go to his head. There are plenty of good actors in this world, but all too few good dramatic critics. THE SILENT DRAMA “The Sex Life’ of the Polyp” Rosert Bencuey’s second Movietone epic, “The Sex Life of the Polyp,” is con- siderably funnier than “The Treasurer's Report,” and the Movietone recording of It was Will Shakespeare who wrote the first review of a “sound” picture when he said, “It is a tale told by an idiot, full of Iris significant that none of the established | sound and fury, signifying nothing.” comedians has appeared to advantage in recent Movietone and Vitaphone pictures. One of the greatest of them all, Chic Sale, is ainfully unfunny; Clark and Mc- Cullough are worse; Yee Cook, Will Mahoney, Willie Howard and other experts fall comparatively flat. That real comedy is possible in the talk- ing movies has been proved by the Bench- ley releases, and by certain portions of Harry Delf's “The Family Picnic.” Oddly enough, it is the quieter and less strenuous form of humor that seems to go best in the talkies; the old heavy-handed gags, so effective in the silent drama, are ruined “Beau Broadway” Lew Copy, Aileen Pringle and Sue Carroll (that wide-eyed miss) acted in “Beau Broadway,” and Malcolm St. Clair directed it. They probably devoted several weeks of time to their respective tasks. But if you were to meet any one of them on the street, and ask him or her (depend- ing on the sex of the questionee) just what “Beau Broadway” was all about, he or she would undoubtedly deny the exis- tence of any such picture. Proressor: Yes, I've given my life to the study of dialectics. Duns Dora: Oo-o, lemme hear you imitate Milt Gross, As one who saw “Beau Broadway” only last night, I can’t remember any- thing about it except that Miss Carroll looked very nice, and I knew that any- way. R. E. Sherwood. Recent Developments, a guide to cur- rent moving pictures, will be found on page 24. when the thwack of the slapstick becomes audible. “Sound”? Pictures Aut the crooks and gyp-artists aren't to be found in the Underworld, which has been exposed in so many recent pictures; there are plenty of them in Hollywood itself, and they are now trying to strengthen weak films by the addition of phony sound effects. “Abie’s Irish Rose,” being a terrible flop as a movie, was withdrawn from the screen, and a special “synchronization” is peng tacked on with a view to forcing the film down the public's throat. The same trick has been tried with i Kings” (of all pictures), The Wedding March” and various others which were made as silent films, and which can only be marred by the addition of a lot of extraneous noise, Tue Fox officials found themselves with a record of Arctic exploration entitled, “Oh, daddy! Look at the fish that has caught me!” comicbooks.com