Life, 1910-02-03 · page 41 of 44
Life — February 3, 1910 — page 41: what you’re looking at
What you’re looking at
This page is primarily **advertising**, not satire or political commentary. The main content is "The Literary Zoo" (continued), which discusses literary criticism rather than cartoon satire. The literary section critiques Edgar Allan Poe's critical work. It quotes Dr. Samuel Johnson's 18th-century essay mocking critics obsessed with "sound as echo to sense"—the idea that word sounds should mirror meanings. The passage suggests Poe, while a "keen critic," produced "provincialism" according to Henry James, though Mabie disagreed. The piece appears to be a literary debate about Poe's critical merit. The rest of the page contains period product advertisements: a Sturtevant mechanical chimney draft system, Strong's Arnica Tooth Soap and Jelly, Peroxide creams, and Marti Fine Shoes. No political cartoons or satirical illustrations are present—only decorative commercial imagery typical of early 20th-century magazine advertising.
📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)
Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.
quatrain eving cial 1 certain ell, wh: 1 years else b “LIFE An easy solu- tion of your chimney and fire-place troubles is to install the Sturtevant “Ready-to-Ran"”’ “Mechanical Draft Standard Residence size price, $35, delivered This little blower is set in the attic, connects with the chimney, and is operated by a button, connecting with electric light current. It creates a chimney suction below, and makes fire-places and furnaces burn absolutely satisfactorily. Any handy man can install it. Fully guaranteed. Order direct by mail or through any hardware or elec- trical dealer, State voltage and current. Booklet H, Sent Free on reqoest. B. F. Sturtevant Co. Hyde Park, Mass. Foremost Makers of Biowing The Literary Zoo (Continued from page 224) “Mr. Longfellow and other plagiar- its” “The initial trochee here,” he temarks, “in each instance, substituted for the iambus, produces, so naturally 3 to seem accidental, a very effective «ho of sound to sense.” Peery A very effective echo of sound to sase! What mocking devil jogged Poe's elbow to write that phrase? A century earlier, in “The Idler,” Dr. Samuel Johnson, no longer lumbering in style, penned a satirical essay that 5s still delightful reading. Of Dick Minim—that_ “inimitably common- Place critic"—he wrote: “He is particularly delighted when he finds the sound an echo to the sense. “* Honor is like the glassy bubble, Which cost philosophers such trouble; Where, one part crack’d, the whole docs fly, And wits are crack’d to find out why.’ “Tt is impossible to utter the (first) two lines emphatically,” says Minim, “without an act like that which they describe; Bubble and Trouble causing a momentary inflation of the cheeks by the retention of the breath, which is afterwards forcibly emitted, as in the practice of blowing bubbles. But the greatest excellence is in the third line, which is crack’d in the middle to express a crack, and then shivers into monosyllables.” ce ee Poe, we have ventured to say, was a “keen critic.” Yet the value of his criticism is debatable. It has, indeed, been the subject of debate, so to speak, by Mr. Henry James and another lit- erary expert, Mr. Mabie. That is to say, Mr. James, unconscious, perhaps, that Mr. Mabie held certain pro- nounced views, has remarked that Poe's collection of critical sketches “ is probably the most complete and ex- quisite specimen of provincialism ever prepared for the edification of men.” Mr. Mabie, on the other hand, is or was of the opinion that “by critical intention, therefore, as well as by Cleanser and Mouth Wash In One Polishes the teeth to dazzling whiteness, while {ts fragrant antiseptic foam reaches every part of the mouth—neutraliz- ing all tooth-destroying acids, preventing dis- gy coloration and decay. Strong’s Arnica Tooth Soap comes in a handy metal box—nothing to break orspill. A convenient cake that insures beauti- ful teeth, bealthy gums and a sweeth breath. At your druggist, 2% cents, Strong’s Arnica Jelly Keeps Your Skin Smooth No need toendure the discomfort of sunburn or winter chapping. Apply with finger tip rub gently into pores. fn’ collapsible metal tubes, 25 cents. swt Weald frvard em pega ae Pkt ond price Guaranteed under the Food and Drug Act, June 30,906. Seria No. 1612. (sf C.H. STRONG & CO., Chicago, U.S.A. couroexD fo EROXIDE CREAM & cisam ‘which clears and) whitens the skin, ne texture ofa youthful complexion and hair, ‘Take no substitute. e CoMFOUXD, PEROXIDE TOOTH POWDER A scientific powder for whitening the teeth. An antiseptic tooth powder which cleanses the mouth and sweetens breath, Recommended for receding gums or Riggs. BATCHELLER IMPORTING CO. NEW YORK. Perfect Shoes and Perfect Shoe Service By Post. We have perfected distinctly new and superior methods of showing and fitting our shoes to patrons at a distance which enables you to take advantage of our extraordinary shoe service no matter where you live. On request we will furnish you with carbon prints of the seasonable models —real photographic reproductions of the shoes themselves—7 x 9 inches in size. We will forward your selections by first express and charge them to your account, if you now have one with us or care to open one by furnish- ing the usual commercial references. We keep perfect records of all our fittings, and after your first order all you need to do is to specify the kind of shoes you want, by wire or post, and the proper shoes will go forward at once, on our usual guaranty of complete satisfaction. Our methods bear no resemblance to the usual mail business, but are a real departure—an extension of our well known personal service—bearing the same relation to ordinary methods that our shoes do to ordinary shoes. Our ready-to-wear shoes, on strictly custom lines and of custom quality, sell from 7 Dollars Upward Shoes to Individual Measure 8 Dollars Upward ARTT} es ARTIL Fine Shoes for Men and Women 1 East 35th Street 183 Michigan Ave. NEW YORK CHICAGO virtue of the possession of genius, which is never provincial, Poe emanci- pated himself, and went far to emanci- pate American literature, from the narrow spirit, the partial judgment, and the inferior standards,” ete. Mr. James and Mr. Mabie are both Academicians. If the time arrives when they shall undertake to settle this question in a polite personal en- counter within Academic walls, may we be close at hand to catch the echo. W. T. Larned. comicbooks.com