Judge — December 16, 1922 — page 19: what you’re looking at

Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.

Drawn by Guy Horr. tion as to where the play was going. Again and again in the game against Center the Harvard hocus-pocus fooled everybody but Roberts. And when a play ran into Roberts it went no farther. rk of Harvard has a somewhat greater range of play than Lovejoy of Yale, but the big blue lineman is far more rugg was probably: the strongest p! any team in the East. He needs alittle more finish but hisnatural equipment, it scems to us, gives him the preference. LTHOUGH Princeton is clearly en- LX titled to the championship. of the Big Three, and probably of the Es well, it does not contribute a v number of play This was distinctly a team rather than group of stars. It is likely that the Princeton team would be able to defeat any hand-picked organization which might be sent against it. Perhaps, it would be a good idea to simplify the All-America problem by just choosing the Tiger eleven. But that would be too easy. Two of the Tigers did stand out. Baker and Treat were conspicuous in all the big games. Treat was the surprise of the season, and by the end of the year he as even better than his brilliant ciate. On our team Baker could be used for the long shots at field goals, with Covington taking care of the shorter ones. asso- ND now for our All-America, which the Best £% differs quite radically fro We Have Scen, Our All-America would line up as follows: Left end, Kirk, Michi- gan; left tackle, Guilan, Brown; left guard, Pixley, Ohio § ;_ center, Love- Joy, Yale: Tight guard, Hubbard, Har- vard; ckle, Ts i quarterbac! right half, Kipke, Michi- full back, ington, Center; gan; left half, Kaw, Cornell; John Thomas, Chicago. 7 “I don’t understand your reason for such actions.” “No, it’s over your head.” This team is probably an improvement over the one which we first mentioned. Kipke of Michigan is a better punter, from all accounts, than anybody we ha’ seen, In addition to having great dis- tance he was exceedingly accurate in kicking out of bounds and again and again dropped the ball into a corner between the ten-yard line and the goal. Thomas is also a better plunging back than any- body has seen in the East. Neither Har- vard nor Yale had a player capable of crumpling up the Princeton line Thomas did in the game at Ch Guilan of Brown was brilliant age both Yale and Harvard and Kirk of Michigan is not only a great defensive end but a fine man to receive the forward pass. Why not? He was trained at Notre Dame. For our substitute All-America backfield we have Castner net Notre Dame and Barchet of the Navy for halves with Red Roberts of Center for fullback and Smythe of the Army at quarterback. comichooks, icom