Judge, 1909-03-13 · page 13 of 15
Judge — March 13, 1909 — page 13: what you’re looking at
What you’re looking at
This page satirizes literary criticism and editing practices of the era. The main feature, "Shears and Paste-Pot," mocks contemporary magazines that offer aspiring writers harsh, commercially-driven feedback on submitted manuscripts. The satire presents fictional "rejections" of famous literary figures—Shakespeare, Burns, Goldsmith, Shelley, Bacon—as if they were amateur writers. The joke is that even canonical authors would be rejected by these philistine editors focused solely on sales appeal over artistic merit. Key satirical points: editors demanding "blood" and violence for public interest; dismissing dialect poetry unless set to music for music halls; rejecting essays entirely; praising only what sells to masses. The criticism is shallow and commercially cynical. This reflects Judge's critique of American publishing's degrading standards—prioritizing sensationalism and "selling capacity" over literary quality, even for genuinely talented writers.
📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)
Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.
WHISKEY For Sale Everywhere W. A. TAYLOR & CO., Sole Agents, New York —<—— The Mosler Safe Co. HAMILTON, O. NEW YORK BOSTON LONDON, ENG. The Largest and Most Modern Safe Works in the World. Buller of FIRE AND BURGLAR-PROOF SAFES, BANK AND SAFE DEPOSIT VAULTS SAFES EXCHANGED SAFES REMOVED SAFES REPAIRED ations and Estimates Furnished. Services of Expert Engineers afforded to Architects. Let Us Solve the Problem of ‘Safes Wiea Tou HY NOT BE AN ARTIST? I eerie sos {ARN 10,8100, PER Weg reer Tineke pron. | “scHGot OF APPLIED ART CHounded 1908.) 7M. HL, Gallery Fine Arta, Dative Creek, | Fine. MEN FOR "MADE AT KEY WEST— HENRY LINDENMEYR & SONS - PAPER WAREHOUSE Noa. 2, 34, and 96 Bleocker Street Branch Warehouse, 29 Beekman Street, New York. ‘ALL KINDS OF PAPER MADE TO ORDER. Collars ans Cuffs 3) p) 3 A, Zes GS: BARKER BRAN “AR wave OF LINEN t2 156 FORQ5S< sizes SHEARS Some of our contemporaries, taking! compassion on the literary aspirant in his difficulties, are prepared to furnish him, by way of help, with a candid criticism of his efforts. So good an ex- ample is worthy of imitation, and to-day we offer the following comments on MSS. that have been submitted to us: sufferably long, and full of wearisome | classical allusions. We feel sure that no editor would accept it. And yet| there are ideas in the poem. You might, | we think, have made a good deal more of Adam's first meeting with Eve. The piece, too, would be greatly improved by |" the use of suitable headlines, such as, Was it Love at First Sight? Interesting Story of How the First Man Met the First Woman. Was Eve a Suffragette? | (N. B.—This last headline, though ir- relevant to the poem, would be sure to prick the public attention in these trou- blous days, and we cannot too strongly insist that the only test of a work is its selling capacity. This is a point too often overlooked by beginners like your- self.) No, we do not think you have enough ability to win a limerick prize. William Shakespeare — Your _ play “‘Hamlet"’ is not without merit. There are indeed passages in it of which no practiced hand would be ashamed, and we have little doubt that if you persevere you will in time write stuff good enough for the provincial stage. What we es- pecially like about this little effort is that there is plenty of blood init. We suggest that you cut out all the solil- ‘oquies, and tone the language up more. Robert Burns—There is no demand for the Scotch dialect poem, even the Scotch |dialect story has gone out of fashion. | Your only chance of success would be to have a few of your efforts set to music, and then forward them to your country- man, Harry Lauder, in the hope of his bringing them out at the halls. You seem to have a leaning toward sent: mental verse. You might develop this! a model ‘In the Twi Twi-Twilight. | rues OF BRAINS vein, taking IGARS Francis Bacon—The public does not read essays. If you aspire to be a lead-| ing-article writer, you must acquire a snappier style. No, we do not allow that any one can be the author of an- other man’s plays. To be the author of a work, one must have written it one’s | self. | Oliver Goldsmith—Your story, ‘The Vicar of Wakefield,” is exceedingly tame, and we do not think any editor would take it. The public is more in- | terested in burglars and detectives than in vicars. But you are capable of im- provement, both in style and plot. Study the works of the late Guy Boothby, and “The Mystery of a Hansom Cab."” Percy B. Shelley—Your lines are very | fair, but you are by no means happy in your choice of subjects. You must study the popular taste more. The public does not want laments. You should give them something in the style of “Put Me Among the Girls."” You would perhaps do better in prose. Why not try your ‘enjoy a genuine luxury try a fi If you would cocktail~ Abbott's Bitters, grape fruit, sugar to an? DASTE-POT LITERARY HELP. | the Garrick, by the production of ‘‘Sam- Don’t Wear a Trug irty Years Experience le a New Discovery fe wn Women or Children That Cares Rupture. Costs You Nothing To Tr, It If you have tried most | After Mad hand at a football story for the maga- zines William Wordsworth—Do not be dis- aif & met with rejection. verses, ‘Will You Love Me in December as You Do in May?” Take these as a model. We think you are quite capable of rising to this level. Yes, a really good coster song, witty and up-to-date, would be sure of acceptance. ili gingea Ex EE. Samuel Johnson—We have glanced through your ‘‘Rasselas."” You appear to have set out with a very hazy idea as to whether you would write in English, or Latin, and the result is a grotesque | mixture. Before beginning a work, it is always well to decide what language you will write it in. Name. Robert Browning—We should not ad- vise you to write songs for the music halls. Your style is not direct enough toget home on the public's heart.—Lon- don Pwich. FOR BOILING PURPOSES. In England, without a doubt, the most popular married couple on the stage is Mr. Arthur Bourchier and Miss Violet Vanbrugh. They have just added an- other to their long list of successes at ORIGINAL DRAWINGS FOR JUDGE FOR SALE We have a limited number on which w be glad toquote prices upon application. These originals cost from ten ta two hundred sJollars each, and after they are used are fol! {rom ‘one to twenty dollars each. JUDGE COMPANY 225 FIFTH AVENUE NEW YORK CITY son.”” It is fifteen years ago since they were married. At the wedding the couple were literally loaded with pres- ents. Among them wasa kettle sent by Miss Ellen Terry. ‘It will do to make | tea for him when he is good,’’ wrote the donor, ‘and to boil him in if he is trou- blesome. Jupce wonders how many actors in America have been married fifteen years—fifteen to the same party, not fifteen times! HOTEL TITCHFIELD Reached by the Hamburg-Amer- ican Line from New York, Royal Mail Line from New York and the United Fruit Company from Boston, Philadelphia and Baltimore Finest Tropical Hotel in the World Accommodations for 400 People All Modern Conveniences : Private Baths, Elevators, Electric Lights, Music, Fishing, Sailing, Tennis, Bathing, Driving, Saddlehorses, Harbor Illumination Every Week, Automobiles To Hire, Garage THE JAMAICA TOURIST INFORMA- TION BUREAU, 673 Boylston Street, Boston, Mass., will, upon request, give de tailed information of Hotel Accommodations, Steamship Sailings, Automobile and Carriag Trips, and Special Attractions of Jamaica AINSLIE & GRABOW CO. Operating: Hotel Lenox, The Brewster, Hotel Tuileries, Hotel Empire, Boston; New Ocean House, Swampscott 673 Boylston Street, Boston, Mass. Tet. oxtora 41410 shall Situated at Port Antonio, Jamaica, British West Indies— In the Land of Perpetual June comicbooks.com