Spawn #5
☆ Be the first to review + Add to your collection — Join freeSpawn #5, titled 'Justice' and published in October 1992, stands as one of the most tonally decisive issues in the early Image Comics era. By introducing and killing Billy Kincaid — a predatory child murderer — within a single issue, Todd McFarlane made an unambiguous creative statement that Spawn would operate outside the moral guardrails of mainstream superhero publishing: the protagonist does what the courts could not, dispensing a brutal, extrajudicial death that left no ambiguity about the series' darker register. The issue simultaneously introduced Sherlee Johnson, Kincaid's final victim, a character so narratively resonant that she anchored her own spinoff series more than thirty years later. Beyond its villain debut, the issue deepened the partnership between detectives Sam Burke and Twitch Williams and reinforced the grim procedural texture that would define the series for years.
ComicBooks.com Value
Show all 13 grades ▾
This exact issue on ebay
Raw / ungraded ▾ $18.26–$37.75 5 listings
More listings for this title
Sell my copy
Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.
We Buy Collections ▸History
The issue was written, penciled, and inked entirely by Todd McFarlane, with colors by Reuben Rude and Steve Oliff and lettering and editing by Tom Orzechowski — the same tight core crew that handled the title's earliest issues. McFarlane has stated in interviews that issue five was a deliberate declaration of creative intent, designed to signal to readers that Spawn would not resemble corporate-owned heroes like Batman. The issue carries a dedication to Will Eisner, a noteworthy editorial gesture paying homage to the foundational cartoonist at a moment when Image was positioning itself as a new wave of creator-owned comics. In 2025, Image reprinted Spawn #5 as a retailer incentive tied to the launch of the spinoff series The Curse of Sherlee Johnson.
Trivia · 8 facts
- First appearance AND death of Billy Kincaid, a serial child killer who poses as an ice cream man to lure victims; despite his in-issue death, Kincaid went on to become one of the series' most recurring villains, returning as a Hellspawn, a ghost, and more.
- First appearance of Sherlee Johnson, a seven-year-old girl established as Kincaid's final victim; her story was revisited more than three decades later in the 2025 spinoff series The Curse of Sherlee Johnson by writer Daniel Henriques and artist Jonathan Glapion.
- Story and all art (pencils, inks, cover) by Todd McFarlane; colors by Reuben Rude and Steve Oliff; lettered and edited by Tom Orzechowski — published October 10, 1992 by Image Comics.
- The issue is dedicated to Will Eisner, as noted on the inside front cover.
- Cyan Fitzgerald's crib contains a Cerebus the Aardvark stuffed animal — an early cross-publisher Easter egg; Dave Sim's character would make his first proper in-story Spawn appearance in issue #10.
- The storyline reveals that Al Simmons, before his death and resurrection as Spawn, had once been hired to assassinate Kincaid but arrived too late as police had already apprehended him — deepening the 'unfinished business' dimension of Spawn's character.
- Spawn delivers Kincaid's corpse — chained up and stabbed with ice cream scoops and popsicle sticks — to the precinct office of detectives Sam Burke and Twitch Williams, a scene that cemented the detectives' role as morally complex witnesses to Spawn's vigilante justice.
- Billy Kincaid was adapted as a major antagonist in the first season of the HBO animated series Todd McFarlane's Spawn, where he was voiced by Ronny Cox; the animated version reimagined him as a senator's son shielded by his father and Jason Wynn.
Cast · 9 characters
Full credits
Reprints
Reprinted in Spawn #5 (1994), Spawn #3 (1995), Spawn #2 (1996), Spawn #5 (1996), Spawn #3/1997 (1997), Spawn TPB #1 (1997), Spawn #3 (1997), As 10 Primeiras Edições de Spawn #[nn] (1997), Spawn: Engendro Infernal #[nn] (1998), Spawn Collection #3 (1998), Spawn - Origem #1 (2007), Spawn Origins Collection #1 (2010), Spawn: Edición Integral #1 (2010), Spawn Origins Collection #1 (2019), Spawn #5 [Second Printing] (2025), Spawn #2, Spawn #2/1996, Spawn Origins Collection #1
Key issues in Spawn
Variants (1)
Reviews
Reader reviews
No reader reviews yet.