Shocking Mystery Cases #51
☆ Be the first to review + Add to your collection — Join freeShocking Mystery Cases #51 stands as a representative artifact of the pre-Comics Code Authority crime-and-horror hybrid genre at its most uninhibited, published in November 1952 when Star Publications was at the height of its output. Its cover — a visceral eyeball-horror composition signed by L.B. Cole — exemplifies the bold, lurid 'poster color' aesthetic that defined Star's newsstand strategy: primary hues punched against black backgrounds designed to stop a browsing reader cold. The series itself occupies a historically interesting structural position, inheriting its numbering directly from Thrilling Crime Cases, illustrating how Star systematically rebranded and retitled its line to ride the crime-comic wave without interrupting publication momentum. As one of the earliest issues to carry the 'Shocking Mystery Cases' banner at issue #51, it documents the precise moment Star pivoted its crime content toward a more sensational, horror-inflected identity just as industry pressure from parent groups and legislators was beginning to mount.
A man confesses to killing someone in cold blood, but is tormented by the victim's ghost returning to haunt him. In a separate story, police investigate a robbery that resulted in murders, eventually tracking down the culprits to a lumber camp where Professor Heinrich and his gang had been hiding in disguise. The investigation reveals clues including a beam from an abandoned shack and a fuse, leading detectives to uncover the criminals' hideout and apprehend them.
In the grimy confines of a New York tenement, Nat Garton, a small-time criminal, is haunted by the aftermath of killing Harry Denfeld—his brother’s murderer—only to find his guilt manifesting as a relentless, terrifying nightmare. As the dead man’s presence grows more real with each waking moment, Garton’s sanity frays under the weight of his own conscience, trapped between fear and the belief that he can never escape what he’s done.
Joe Catalino, a man who once escaped justice by framing others, now faces a reckoning when a series of violent murders tied to his past resurface. As Detective Edward Burke and his team investigate the death of Mary Davito, they uncover a trail of blood and vengeance linked to old underworld debts—and a man named Nico Vacco, nursing a silent fury since being betrayed. With the past closing in, Joe finds himself hunted not by the law, but by the ghosts of his own crimes.
In the midst of a violent storm, a surgical team at Hilton General Hospital struggles to save a patient’s life—only for a sudden blackout to reveal a shocking murder during the operation. As the sheriff investigates the seven people present, suspicion falls on Nurse Mannes when her torn glove betrays her, leading to a desperate confession tied to a long-buried grudge against the patient, Judge Perry.
In the winter of 1923, three brothers—Roy, Hugh, and Ray D'Autremont—attempt a daring robbery of the Southern Pacific Fast Express, only to find themselves trapped in a burning train car after a botched heist. Fleeing through the Oregon wilderness, they are pursued by a relentless manhunt that spans years, fueled by a single clue: a pair of overalls and three cans of corn left behind. As the police close in, the brothers' fate hangs in the balance, with their past catching up to them in unexpected ways.
ComicBooks.com Value
Show all 21 grades ▾
Find on ebay
Read it digitally
Sell my copy
Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.
We Buy Collections ▸History
Star Publications was co-founded in 1949 by artist-editor L.B. Cole and lawyer Gerhard Kramer, built substantially on inventory acquired when Curtis Publishing's Novelty Press exited the comics market. Cole served as both cover artist and likely editor on the title, and the Grand Comics Database records his editorial role on this issue with a question mark indicating the attribution is probable but not fully documented. Interior content was handled by Jay Disbrow — one of Star's most prominent in-house creators of original material — alongside Myron Fass, though GCD indexers note that at least one story reprinted here had its original 'M Fass' signature erased, and that mixed art styles across Fass-credited pages suggest he may have subcontracted portions of the work to other hands, possibly including Walter Johnson. Several of the interior stories were reprints drawn from earlier Fox Feature Syndicate and Star titles such as Famous Crimes, a common cost-control practice across the Star line.
Trivia · 8 facts
- Published November 1952 by Star Publications (some retailer databases list September 1952; the Grand Comics Database cites the Catalog of Copyright Entries, 1952 Periodicals as confirming the on-sale/publication date).
- Cover art by L.B. Cole — a signed eyeball-horror composition — representing his signature 'poster color' approach: bold primary colors, often over black backgrounds.
- Interior story art credited to Jay Disbrow and Myron Fass; GCD notes indicate Fass's original signature was erased from at least one reprinted story, and stylistic evidence suggests possible ghost-art by Walter Johnson.
- The series title Shocking Mystery Cases continues the numbering of the earlier Star title Thrilling Crime Cases (1950), with Shocking Mystery Cases picking up at #50 after Thrilling Crime Cases ended at #49.
- Issue contains five stories: 'A Murderer's Reward,' 'Corpse — Without Teeth!,' 'Bloody Hands of Vengeance,' 'Weird Operation!!,' and 'The Shocking Tunnel Murders.'
- Story content mixes crime-morality tales (a guilt-ridden hood, a vengeful nurse, a train robbery) with horror-adjacent framing, reflecting the genre blend common to pre-Code Star titles.
- The issue was later collected and reprinted in Shocking Mystery Cases Volume 1 (PS Artbooks, 2023), which gathered issues #51–53, 55–56, and 60, marking the first time much of this Star/Fox-sourced material appeared in print since its original release.
- Jay Disbrow is identified by multiple sources as one of Star Publications' most prolific contributors of original, non-reprint material across the line's run.
Full credits
Reprints
↩ Reprints Murder Incorporated #6 (1948), Famous Crimes #6 (1949)
Reprinted in Gwandanaland Comics #1004
Reviews
Reader reviews
No reader reviews yet.