Sherlock Holmes #1
Sherlock Holmes #1 (Charlton, October 1955) stands as one of the earliest attempts by an American comic-book publisher to give Arthur Conan Doyle's detective his own dedicated monthly title, presenting Holmes and Watson in all-new pastiche adventures rather than adaptations of the canonical stories. The series represents a mid-century bridge between pulp-era detective fiction and the emerging visual storytelling of American comics, and its brevity — only two issues — makes it a compact but telling document of how the industry tested the market for literary-hero comics in the pre-Silver Age period. Its built-in prose filler story, added strictly to meet postal requirements for subscriber mailings, also offers a small window into the creative and logistical realities facing low-budget publishers of the era.
Sherlock Holmes investigates a case involving Sir Reginald's estate and a large bank account, meeting with Chief Walters of the local police. About a month prior, Sir Reginald's housekeeper received a frantic phone call from his neighbor Nat Borden reporting a terrible fight between the two men. Holmes arrives to find the men have been scrapping and must stop them before they kill each other, then recovers a ruby that was stolen. The story concludes with supernatural elements as a spirit named Diane appears, revealing herself as more than a friend and bestowing a gift upon her grandfather before vanishing into the land of spirits.
Sherlock Holmes looks forward to hearing the great violinist Senor Carini perform his farewell concert—but the maestro is found dead in his locked dressing room, apparently by his own hand with cyanide gas. Holmes suspects murder, not suicide, and devises an ingenious trap using his own violin skills to expose the true culprit and their carefully laid scheme.
When a British diplomat vanishes from his estate with no body and no proof, Sherlock Holmes is called in to investigate—and all suspicion falls on the man's quarrelsome neighbor. Holmes examines the scene, questions the locals, and uncovers a peculiar detail that sets him on an unexpected course of action in "Love Thy Neighbor." With characteristic patience and a keen eye for the smallest clues, the famous detective devises an ingenious trap that will take two months to spring.
When Sherlock Holmes accepts an invitation to lecture at an American university, an FBI agent approaches him with an urgent case: Prince Marat's priceless ruby, the Star of the East—a symbol of power to his people—has been stolen and replaced with a clever fake. Holmes quickly suspects the theft may be an inside job, with the Prince's own aide harboring dangerous ambitions of his own. As gangsters close in and the case spirals into danger, Holmes must uncover the real culprit before the Prince loses both the jewel and his throne.
Dr. Neff, the celebrated stage ghost-breaker, teams up with Inspector J. J. O'Malley to investigate a sinister con artist named Professor Lorenzo, whose séances promise contact with spirits—but are really fleecing wealthy victims of cash and jewels. When Neff infiltrates Lorenzo's next séance, he uncovers an elaborate mechanical and theatrical scheme designed to fool the audience and make off with their gifts.
ComicBooks.com Value
Show all 13 grades ▾
Find on ebay
Read it digitally
Sell my copy
Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.
We Buy Collections ▸History
The series was produced at Charlton Comics' Derby, Connecticut plant, with art attributed to staff artist Bill Molno and scripts tentatively attributed to Joe Gill — Charlton's remarkably prolific primary writer, who routinely produced upward of 100 pages of scripts per week across every genre the company published. The October 1955 cover date places the issue's production squarely in the aftermath of Hurricane Diane, which flooded Charlton's facility in August 1955 and destroyed hundreds of thousands of dollars' worth of inventory and printing equipment, forcing the company to outsource printing for months; it is plausible the Holmes launch proceeded despite this disruption. Collectors and historians have noted that Charlton frequently took liberties with licensed characters and that the series' quick cancellation after just two issues may reflect pushback from the Conan Doyle estate's licensing representatives.
Trivia · 8 facts
- Published by Charlton Comics, cover-dated October 1955; the series ran for exactly two issues (the second appearing in March 1956).
- Interior stories are original pastiches — not adaptations of any specific Arthur Conan Doyle tale — featuring Holmes and Watson solving new mysteries.
- Issue #1 contains three Holmes stories: 'Sherlock Holmes in the Final Curtain,' 'Love Thy Neighbor,' and 'Sherlock Holmes and the Star of the East.'
- A fourth story, 'Smashing the Spook Racket,' features Dr. Neff (the Original Ghost-Breaker) alongside Inspector O'Malley — Holmes does not appear in it.
- A two-page uncredited prose short story titled 'Tough Guy' was included specifically to establish literary merit and qualify the comic for discounted second-class subscriber postal rates.
- Art is attributed to Charlton staff artist Bill Molno; scripting is tentatively attributed to Joe Gill, though Charlton credits were rarely printed and a definitive byline has not been confirmed.
- A facsimile reprint edition was later published by Wildside Press (ISBN 9781479421862), making the original content accessible to modern readers without hunting for the original newsstand copy.
- Charlton's Derby, Connecticut facility was devastated by Hurricane Diane flooding in August 1955 — the same month this issue was produced — destroying printing equipment and original artwork, providing important context for the series' short lifespan.
Cast · 2 characters
Full credits
Reprints
↩ Reprints Racket Squad in Action #3 (1952)
Reprinted in Gwandanaland Comics #1060
Reviews
Reader reviews
No reader reviews yet.