Josie #42
☆ Be the first to review + Add to your collection — Join freeJosie #42 (August 1969) is the pivot point of one of Archie's most consequential editorial reinventions: it marks the first appearance of Alan M. Mayberry, the muscular blond folk singer who displaced Albert as Josie's love interest and went on to become a permanent fixture of the franchise across comics, animation, and live-action. The issue also introduced — in embryonic form — the music-band concept that would fully crystallize three issues later in Josie and the Pussycats #45, directly enabling Hanna-Barbera's landmark 1970 Saturday morning animated series. In a single summer, Archie's editorial team used this issue to launch a new romantic triangle (Josie–Alan M.–Alexandra) and plant the seed of a band called The Jesters, a storytelling experiment that immediately redirected the title toward the all-girl group format that would define the property for the next five decades. The 1969 revamp, of which #42 is the opening chapter, also set the stage for Valerie Brown's introduction — a milestone in representation for Saturday morning animation.
In "Minstrel Man," Alexandra takes a sudden interest in Alan M. and offers to sponsor his band, setting off a chain of unlikely connections. She meets Gloomer, the band’s drummer whose gloom is so deep it borders on despair, and Instant Replay, the one bright soul who can make sense of his cryptic mutterings—making this a story of music, melancholy, and unexpected hope. Written by Frank Doyle and brought to life with Dan DeCarlo’s expressive art, Rudy Lapick’s inks, Barry Grossman’s colors, and Bill Yoshida’s lettering, this 1969 issue features a cover by Dan DeCarlo and Rudy Lapick.
In "Minstrel Man," Alex, smitten with Josie, hires a mysterious new guitarist named Alan M. to serenade her—only to find Josie quickly charmed by the musician’s talent, while Alan seems to care more for his music than for the girl who’s fallen for him.
In "Dismal Drummer," Alexandra’s sponsorship of Alan M.’s band brings her face-to-face with Gloomer, the perpetually gloomy drummer, and his surprisingly upbeat girlfriend, Instant Replay—the one person who can make sense of his endless mutterings.
In "Jester Melody," Jo and her friends are inspired by a playful argument between Josie and Alexandra to rebrand their musical act—Alan, Gloomer, and Alex finally find their groove, and Melody sparks a new name that captures their chaotic charm: "Alan and the Jesters."
ComicBooks.com Value
More listings for this title
Sell my copy
Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.
We Buy Collections ▸History
The Josie property had begun as a failed newspaper-strip pitch by Dan DeCarlo, who named the character after his wife Josie DeCarlo; after syndicates passed, DeCarlo brought the strip to Archie's Richard Goldwater, who approved it as a comic book in 1963. Through the mid-1960s, writer Frank Doyle — Archie's prolific head writer who penned over 10,000 stories for the publisher — collaborated with DeCarlo to build out the supporting cast, including the Cabot twins. By 1969, with Filmation's Archie Show a proven Saturday morning hit and Hanna-Barbera actively seeking to develop a comparable Archie-owned property, Archie Comics undertook a deliberate overhaul of the Josie title issue-by-issue across the summer and fall of that year, beginning with the character introductions in #42 and culminating in the full band relaunch with issue #45.
Trivia · 8 facts
- First appearance of Alan M. Mayberry (full name Alan M. Mayberry), introduced as a heavily built blond folk singer; he would become Josie's primary love interest and a core franchise character in comics, the 1970 Hanna-Barbera cartoon, and subsequent adaptations.
- Issue cover-dated August 1969, published by Archie Comics (Radio Comics Inc. indicia) under the title Josie — the series had previously been titled She's Josie (issues #1–16) before being renamed Josie with issue #17 (December 1965).
- In this issue, Alan M. and Alexander Cabot form a band called 'Alan and the Jesters' — the first in-story attempt at a music-band concept in the title, which did not survive beyond this single issue before the editors pivoted to the all-girl Pussycats format.
- Last appearance of Pepper's boyfriend Sock (Socrates), who was written out of the series along with Pepper and Albert as part of the 1969 character overhaul.
- Art by Dan DeCarlo (pencils), inks by Rudy Lapick; scripts attributed to Frank Doyle, the long-time head writer of Archie Comics who co-developed the Josie cast from its inception.
- The issue was part of a deliberate three-issue editorial sequence: #42 introduced Alan M.; #43 (September 1969) introduced Sebastian the cat and Alexandra's witchcraft powers; and #45 (December 1969) launched the Pussycats band and introduced Valerie Smith (later Brown), with the title simultaneously renamed Josie and the Pussycats.
- Stories from this issue were reprinted in Laugh Comics Digest #42 (September 1982) and Betty & Veronica Jumbo Comics Double Digest #20 (August 1990), extending the issue's readership across multiple decades.
- The 1969 Josie revamp was directly catalyzed by Hanna-Barbera approaching Archie Comics after the success of Filmation's The Archie Show; the animated Josie and the Pussycats series premiered on CBS on September 12, 1970, less than 14 months after this issue's publication.
Full credits
Reprints
Reprinted in Laugh Comics Digest / Laugh Comics Digest Magazine / Laugh Digest Magazine #42 (1982), Laugh Comics Digest / Laugh Comics Digest Magazine / Laugh Digest Magazine #44 (1983), Betty & Veronica (Jumbo Comics) Double Digest #20 (1990), Best of Josie and the Pussycats #1 (2001)
Key issues in Josie
Reviews
Reader reviews
No reader reviews yet.