I Love You #28

A young woman caught between two suitors takes center stage on this May 1960 Charlton romance issue, her face framed dramatically between heart-shaped portraits of two handsome young men — Blaine and Steven — while a second scene below shows the couples in quieter, more uncertain moments. The cover caption for "Falling in Love Again" sets up a story of romantic indecision with real emotional pull, and the bold yellow and red palette gives the whole thing an irresistible mid-century warmth. Joe Sinnott's pencils and Vince Colletta's inks bring a polished, expressive quality to the lovelorn drama — and as a bonus, readers in 1960 could enter to win TWA round trips to Disneyland or New York right from the cover.