comicbooks.com Join Free
First Love Illustrated #40 cover
Cover: Warren Kremer & Al Avison

First Love Illustrated #40

May 1954 · Harvey · 0.10 USD
☆ Be the first to review + Add to your collection — Join free

"Prisoner of Passion" in First Love Illustrated #40 (1954) tells the poignant story of Frances, a young woman released from reform school after four years for a crime she committed under pressure from her boyfriend Lou. Now working at a factory, she keeps her past hidden—until she meets Johnny, a new worker who stirs feelings she thought were lost. As their bond deepens, Johnny’s impulsive act of stealing the payroll to spoil her sets off a quiet but powerful reckoning, testing the strength of their love and her resolve to live honestly. With heartfelt storytelling and expressive art by John Prentice, and a striking cover by Warren Kremer and Al Avison, this issue captures a moment of fragile hope in a world where second chances are rare.

Contains 5 stories
Prisoner of Passion
5 pp · Romance
Nora OrlokiRusk GormanCam BellowsMike "Pop" OrlokiMrs. Orloki

In "Prisoner of Passion," Nora finds herself caught between duty and desire when her father pressures her to marry the harsh steel plant foreman Rusk, despite her growing feelings for the quiet newcomer Cam. When Rusk threatens her family and Cam, a tense confrontation forces Cam to stand up—not just for love, but for the kind of courage Nora’s new country promises.

Second Date-Bait!
1 pp · Romance
The Barrier
5 pp · Romance
ReneeAlan MorganDanPeg
Trial by Fire
5 pp · Romance
Carrie KimballWade CaseyHurd PeytonUncle Jack

In "Trial by Fire," newly graduated Carrie faces a crisis of faith when she discovers her fiancé Hurd strayed during her time away. Seeking clarity, she retreats to her uncle’s ranch, where foreman Wade shows her kindness and attention—though her heart remains with Hurd. As she weighs her choices, Carrie must decide what love truly means before returning to the city to face her future.

Love Was My Sin
5 pp · Romance
Frances M. BlairLou OnslowMrs. BlairMr. BlairJohnny Williams

In "Love Was My Sin," Frances, newly released from reform school after four years for a crime she committed at her boyfriend Lou’s urging, tries to start over with a factory job and a hardened heart. When she meets Johnny, a kind-hearted new worker, she’s drawn to him despite her fears—until his generosity threatens to undo everything she’s trying to rebuild. The story unfolds with quiet intensity, exploring how love and redemption can coexist even when the past refuses to stay buried.

ComicBooks.com Value

Our Model is In Beta
Raw (Good) $54
CGC 9.4 · 1 in census $1,797*
CGC 9.2 · 2 in census $1,153*
CGC 9.0 none in existence
CGC 8.5 · 1 in census $559*
CGC 8.0 none in existence
CGC 7.5 none in existence
Show all 7 grades
CGC 7.0 · 1 in census $292*
* estimate — limited direct-sales data at this grade
Our model’s value — refined as new sales data arrives · CGC census counts shown where available

Find on

Search eBay for First Love Illustrated #40
No confirmed live listings for this exact issue right now — this opens an eBay search.

Sell my copy

Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.

We Buy Collections ▸
Fast, fair offers · we handle grading & shipping

Full credits

artist, inker John Prentice
cover pencils Warren Kremer
cover inks Al Avison

Reprints

Reprinted in First Love Illustrated #72 (1957), Hi-School Romance Datebook #3 (1963)

Reviews

Reader reviews

No reader reviews yet.