Action Comics #51
Action Comics #51 holds a firm place in Golden Age Superman history as the first appearance of the Prankster (Oswald Hubert Loomis), a gimmick-based criminal who would become, for a time, one of Superman's most frequently recurring foes of the 1940s and '50s. The character's debut introduced a distinct storytelling flavor to the Superman rogues' gallery — an elaborate-joke-as-crime-scheme approach that deliberately echoed Batman's Joker, adding a lighter, more whimsical adversary to counterbalance the more physically threatening villains Superman faced. Notably, the story ends with the Prankster escaping unpunished, a genuinely rare outcome for Golden Age Superman villains that gave the character built-in sequel potential and helped establish him as a recurring presence. The issue also captures Superman's mythos at a transitional moment: by mid-1942 both Clark Kent and Lois Lane had visually evolved closer to their familiar Silver Age appearances.
In "The Case of the Crimeless Crimes," Clark and Lois investigate a baffling mystery when a mysterious figure known only as the Prankster pulls off a bank heist—only to deposit a bag overflowing with cash and vanish without a trace. Written by Jerry Siegel and illustrated by John Sikela, this 1942 adventure blends mystery and early superhero flair, with Fred Ray's striking cover capturing the enigma of the Prankster’s odd crime.
In "The Case of the Crimeless Crimes," Clark and Lois investigate a baffling mystery when the enigmatic Prankster pulls off a bank heist that defies logic—stealing nothing but leaving behind a bag stuffed with cash, deposited with a smile. The story unfolds with a clever twist on crime and justice, as the duo tries to unravel the mind behind the prank.
ComicBooks.com Value
Show all 19 grades ▾
Find on ebay
Sell my copy
Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.
We Buy Collections ▸History
The issue was scripted by Superman co-creator Jerry Siegel and drawn by John Sikela, one of Joe Shuster's principal studio assistants — though the artwork was signed under the Shuster studio name, consistent with DC's production practices of the period. Whitney Ellsworth edited the book, with future Superman editor Mort Weisinger serving as uncredited assistant. The cover and a second interior Superman story were both rendered by Fred Ray, whose credits on this issue were for decades misattributed to Wayne Boring in at least one prominent reference volume, only later corrected through verification by Ray and artist Jack Burnley. The issue is a 68-page anthology reflecting DC's wartime format, featuring backup strips for the Vigilante, Zatara, Congo Bill, Mr. America, and others alongside the key Superman lead.
Trivia · 7 facts
- First appearance of the Prankster (Oswald Hubert Loomis), a gimmick-based criminal who relies on elaborate practical jokes rather than superpowers, debuting in the story 'The Case of the Crimeless Crimes.'
- Created by writer Jerry Siegel and artist John Sikela; the artwork was published under the Joe Shuster studio byline per standard DC practice of the era.
- Cover art and a second interior Superman story ('The Prankster and the Foolproof Plot') by Fred Ray — credits long misattributed to Wayne Boring in the Abbeville Press reference book, later corrected by Fred Ray and Jack Burnley.
- Edited by Whitney Ellsworth (credited as F. W. Ellsworth), with Mort Weisinger and Murray Boltinoff as uncredited assistant editors.
- The Prankster escapes at the story's conclusion — an unusual outcome for a debut Superman villain of the Golden Age, and one that helped position him as a recurring antagonist throughout the 1940s and into the 1950s.
- The lead Superman story was reprinted in Superman: The Action Comics Archives Vol. 3 and Superman Chronicles Vol. 9.
- Backup features in this 68-page anthology include stories starring the Vigilante, Zatara (written by Gardner Fox), Congo Bill, Mr. America, and Three Aces, with art contributions from Mort Meskin, Bernard Baily, Henry Boltinoff, and others.
Full credits
Reprints
Reprinted in Superman in Action Comics #1 (1993), Superman: The Action Comics Archives #3 (2001), The Superman Chronicles #9 (2011), Superman: The Golden Age Omnibus #3 (2017), Superman: The Golden Age #5 (2020), O Lobinho (2ª Série) #66
Key issues in Action Comics
Reviews
Reader reviews
No reader reviews yet.