Life, 1913-10-30 · page 31 of 40
Life — October 30, 1913 — page 31: what you’re looking at
What you’re looking at
This page's main satirical article attacks the hypocrisy of high-society opera critics. The piece argues that wealthy Metropolitan Opera patrons and New York newspaper critics have monopolized discussion of the city's new "popular opera" experiment, despite having no real stake in it. The satire's core point: the actual working-class New Yorkers who *actually use* affordable opera—riding subways, wearing modest clothes, studying programs seriously—never get heard. Yet their genuine enjoyment proves the opera's success more than any snobbish critic's opinion. The comparison to baseball fans clinches it: just as working people don't brag about loving baseball (they simply enjoy it), the common opera-goer's silent appreciation speaks louder than society critics' pretentious commentary. The article mocks class-based cultural gatekeeping—the assumption that only elites deserve authority over artistic judgment.
📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)
Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.
Do you want to be well? Of course’ you dot It isn't so difficult. jablished a booklet called “The Way to Get Well al It tells you all about our facilities for getting well—| | God Given—Man Made? 1 have feat GEO. F. ADAMS, Mgr. HOTEL CHAMBERLIN FORTRESS MONROE, VA. P.O. Box 103 Vox Populi RACTICALLY every opinion, com- ment and criticism offered thus jar on New York's latest experiment in popular opera has come from a class of people whom such an undertaking does notin the least concern. Wealthy directors of the Metropolitan and sim- ilar institutions, self-styled “ opera- lovers” of the social aristocracy, and the hot-house critics of the New York daily papers have filled the air with patronizing approval or doubtful maunderings of the non-committal type. But for the millions of Ameri- " can citizens who really want opera at = popular prices no voice has yet spoken. These are not the people who figure in the newspapers or in the pretentious absurdities of high society. They are the people who enjoy a play even when it is given by a stock company, the people v:ho prefer an inexpensive but satisfactory table d’hote dinner to the exaggerated indigestibilities of a ERLE “A new age had bloomed—one with the spirit of gaiety, of youth uponit. The exquisitely Intricate beauties of the Italians were taken and made playful, made French. The spirit of the age burst into shapes of silver.” From “Chats About Silver,” sent free upon request “Francis I” pattern breathes the spirit of this glowing time. It is but one among the Reed & Barton silver forms—that alike include inexpen- sive trifles for modest homes and elaborately conceived services for great ones. Each piece, however small, is of exclusive de- sign—a conceded distinction in a silver shape. Offered by Leading Jewelers Everywhere Reed & Barton Taunton, Massachusetts Represented at Fifth Avenue and 32d Street, 4 Maiden Lane, New York ee Boston Chicago San Francisco ” Delicious in flavor, satisfying and_sustai ing. of the highest standard of purity, MAILLARD'S BREAKFAST COCOA is Broadway café, the people who, when not promenade lanzuidly between the ny rightly acclaimed everywhere as the ideal beverage for Breakfast, Lunch and Supper. MAILLARD'S VANILLA CHOCOLATE —a pure, wholesome sweetmeat, of the rarest quality and flavor. At Leading Dealers Fifth Avenue at 35th Street CHOCOLATES, BONBONS, FRENCH BONBONNIERES Afternoon tea served in the Luncheon Restaurant, three to siz they go to hear an opera, look at the stage, not at the horseshoe full of ostentatious snobbery. These people come to the opera in the subway and on the surface cars, not in automobiles. They wear su ficient clothing, but of a kind not cal- culated to distract the attention of their neighbors. They listen to the music intelligently and with every evi- dence of sincere enjoyment. They do acts, but study their programs and i- brettos or discuss the performance with animated enthusiasm No opinion has yet been publicly ex- pressed hy this element in our popula- tion, None is necessary. The voice of the people is heard in actions rather than in words. Has known a hardened bleacherite to an- nounce that he was fond of baseball? S. S. anyone ever comicbooks.com