ComicBooks.com Register / Loginit's free!

Life, 1910-11-17 · page 36 of 44

Life — November 17, 1910 — page 36: what you’re looking at

📖 Open the full issue in the page-flip reader →
Life — November 17, 1910 — page 36: Life, 1910-11-17

What you’re looking at

This excerpt critiques how university education ruins writers' natural talent. The author argues that while Yale undergraduates write *correctly*, they've become boring—their polish strips away originality. Conversely, grammar school children write *badly* but powerfully, with delightful unintentional humor. The satire's point: formal education teaches students to imitate established models (Jeffries, Pater, Addison, Johnson) so thoroughly that they lose spontaneity and voice. Examples of children's malapropisms—"Senhedrin was composed of seventy men of reclining years"—are presented as superior to polished mediocrity because they contain genuine, if accidental, wit. The piece laments that promising young writers, once trained into "good style," become tedious—another talented voice lost to academic conformity.

📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)

Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.

EEE RIPE, RICH AND MELLOW UNIQUE IN PURITY. OF HIGHEST STANDARD IN QUALITY. GUARANTEED BY ITS PROPRIETORS UNDER THE NATIONAL PURE FOOD LAW AN ABSOLUTELY PURE RYE WHISKEY HUNTER BALTIMORE RYE Sold at all fretctass cafes and by Jobbers. WM. LANANAN & SON, laltincre, Md, ICOOOOOS: The Literary Zoo (Continued from page 879) Post—writes so much like his class- mates that his originality seems to have evaporated. He finds it casy enough to write well, but impossible to be interesting. He has been forced to study the great models, to form his style upon theirs. He bores us by writing like Jeffries or Pater or Addi- son or the great Dr. Samuel Johnson himself, What becomes of the bad writers? They are turned by our universities into good ones. The disastrous effects of the process upon literature are well illustrated through comparison of the themes worked out by the class in English at Yale with the “ composi- tions” of the public school children J : in any large city. Good as is the Eng- lish now written by the undergrad- uates in even the freshman class, one never sees it quoted outside the class- room. But the English written by the boys and girls in a fourth grade or grammar school is bad enough to make delightful reading. It finds its way frequently enough into the news- papers as typical school boys’ “ howl- ers.” It is barbarous and hence pow- erful. What delicious violations of every canon of correct criticism, what freshness of imbecility, what instances of that finest form of the sense of humor, its unconscious manifestation! Again and yet again the teacher, going over the papers submitted by the little ones, extracts a masterpiece here and there, irresistibly quotable because of its crudity and the countless flaws of style so odious to The Evening Post. Let us repeat a few. They have gone the rounds of the newspapers many a time, but the labor of reading them twice will not be vain: “Eve sinned out of curiosity more than liking for that particular fruit.” “The Semitic races were the half- breeds, from semi, half.” Senhedrin was composed of seventy mca of reclining years and great learning.” With respect to_the conversation re- corded in John, Chapter 3: “ Nicode- mus began the harangue, but could not take it all in at one gasp.” By and by the pupils whose faults of style rendered their English so quotable will be writing so well at college as to bore us. The lad who could set down in perfect good faith his idea that “a vacuum is a large empty space where the Pope stops” will never, when he reaches Harvard, achieve anything as fine. He will have been shamed by ridicule or improved hy study of the best models into a good style. Another bad writer will have been lost. Nurses Outfitting Association 54.W. 39th St., New York Meme Bareas Howe Fifth Aveave we ORRECT For Maids For House and Street Imported Novelties Uniforms Aprons Collars Catfs Caps ABSOLUTELY FREE A 5-Vol. Set of MAUPASSANT Illustrated—4¥4 x 7 inches. Bound in Art Cloth. Each volume contains more than 300 pages. RDINARILY we could offer these sets only at the regular price. An unexpected transaction has en- abled us to add a few thousand sub- scribers to our mag- azine, That means new readers for PEAR N'S MAGAZINE. Now we're risking the price of these books that you will be continual read ers year after year, and we believe that it is good bus ness to let you have these sets_of DE MAUPASS. ABSOLUTELY FREE in order to get you started. You are NOT to pay anything for the set NOW wx AFTER you receive it OUR PROPOSITION The price of PEARSON'S MAGAZINE is 15 cents 2 copy, which, if purchased by single copies, costs $1.89 a year, For boxing, wrapping, and express chargo on the five volumes of DE MAUPASSANT, 150 cen. dlete stories, illustrated, printed from new large tye copyrighted 1910, size’ 434x7. it costs an average of 80 cents each, according to distance; so send us $249 for the year's subscription to the the absolute cost of shipping and deli THERE ARE NO FURTHER CHARGES OF ANY KIND WHATEV:R You may send only 70 cents as good faith, and the books will be shipped you, with the Special’ Privilese of examination, before you pay the balance (the press companies charge 10 cents more for these collec: shipments); or send the full amount at once and save 10 cents. Send us $2.60 in money, stamps, check or money order. If the books are not satisfactory is every way, without quibble or question, we will ra you cither’the 70 cents or $2.60 paid. French Classics IRENCH authors have written m tales which, because of false con modesty, have been, until recent tr unknown to those who read only Englis modesty and unfair prejudice have depr merriest_ and_ liveliest tales ever written, Guy ée Maupassant's eventful career gave him ideas, st ations and local color for his unsurpassed stone. Strong in imagination. overflowing with natural e- thusiasm and passion in his study of human life an¢ phases of human conduct, things really happenite— not as we imagine they might or as we would—BUT THE REAL DOIN OF LIFE—is w Maupae sant always givgs us. His dramatic instinct, his ate ations and his’ climaxes are overwhelming. Thee absorbing stories should be in every library—tales of travel, mystery, adventure, comedy, pathos and tragedy, love and realism. You Must Write at ONCE x PEARSON'S MAGAZINE, 425 East 24th St., New York Cty fine and fee f] ine, soiritand soda beverages. Appetisia . ful, to use with Grape Fruit, Oranges, Wine Jey. Wine Merchants or Druggists, Sampte by mail, 28¢ In stamps, C. W. ARROTT & CO., Raltimore, m4 It is fatuous to retort that grown men and women still live who write badly. The trouble with these bad writers is that they enlist talents of good writers to accomplish the toil of composition for them, The loss to literature is aggravated by the detail that good writers are invariably 100 poverty stricken to employ bad writers to express their ideas originally. What (Continued on page 8 comicbooks.com