Life, 1908-12-17 · page 25 of 28
Life — December 17, 1908 — page 25: what you’re looking at
What you’re looking at
This page is primarily **advertisements and travel notices** with one significant editorial commentary piece. The main satirical content is "MORE 'FREEDOM OF THE PRESS'" — a critique of theatrical censorship. It reports that dramatic critic **Walter Prichard Eaton** was apparently forced out from the *New York Sun* because his negative reviews of plays displeased theater managers. Life alleges that the Theatrical Trust (a powerful monopoly controlling American theater) pressured advertisers to withdraw from the *Sun*, costing the paper substantial revenue (calculated as $1,050+ per page). The satire is bitter: Life mocks the concept of "freedom of the press" by documenting how financial leverage — not official censorship — silences honest criticism. Eaton is praised as a serious, fair critic whose only offense was condemning plays with ethical/aesthetic problems. The surrounding advertisements (liquor, steamship tours, art schools, bitters) are unrelated commercial content typical of the era.
📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)
Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.
© wire: Comen- scue a cunning . about send a to the ned to LA Jee, oIsA Bottled Delight =a mixed-to-measure blend Of fine old liquors aged to a wonderful’ mellowness. ince drinks CrusB Cock- a S and:you’ll never want the guess-work kind again. ! Martini (ein base) and Manhattan (whisky base) are the most popular. Get a bottle from your dealer G.F. HEUBLEIN & BRO. corres: Res G2- - TARTFORD = NEW YORK —LONOON i The Best Bitter Liqueur nderberg ne World's Best - © Bitters For pleasure, for rofit, for both. enefits while it stimulates. Cre- ates bppetite and aids digestion. Solid Everywhere. LUYTIfS BROTHERS U.S, Agen New York EARN $25 7 70 sioo PER R WEEK ‘soa FARN,S25,T0,6100 PER snguorarge i ep cusiatng or, Ost ae een ae ccafl teaching. “Rupert instructors. Pesitless | ced competent workers, Write for Mandseme ‘SCHUOL OP APPLIED ART (Pounded 1898.) Ney Gallery Pine Artspbattlo Creck, Mich. Ry On! natural ripening and metlowing of P. B. elves it a flavor which cannot be obtained ermentation Is forced. an honest brew of pare naster brewers. It's the owed. Try it. it leading Hotels, Restaurants and Cafés, KER HILL BREWERIES A.G VAN NOSTRAND,SUMESNO., Sdaws. COOK’S NILE STEAMERS)| the fist Derby made in America was a Cairo to Luxor and the First Cataract. RAMES| -Dec. 22| RAMES! EGYPT. 3| fevers RAMESESTHE GH _dan, 8 | RAMESES Til and weekly thereafter, connecting with service for Second Cataract, Khartoum. Uganda, &c. Cook's Express Steamers sali every Monday and Friday Luxurious dababeahs and special steamers for charter to families and private parties. TOURS TO THE ORIENT 424 ANNUAL SERIES, Leave Jan. 7, 9, 23, Feb. 13 18, 27. 1909, Travel de Luxe through Egypt, Moly Land, The Levant, etc. INDIVIDUAL TRAVEL TICKETS EVERYWHERE THOS. COOK & SON New York, Boston, Philadelphia, Chicago _ San Francisco, and 140 Offices Abroad MORE “FREEDOM OF THE PRESS” From a paragraph in the department of pungent dramatic criticism in New York Lire, we learn simultaneously that Mr. Walter Prichard Eat has published a most interesting study in “ The American Stage of To-Day,”’ and that he has but recently disappeared from the columns of the New York Sun as dramatic critic. We are led to in fer, from the more than usually guarded language of Mr. Metcalfe in Lire, that Mr. Eaton has left the Sun because his criticism of plays was not palatable to the Theatrical Trust. A rumor is spread abroad by peregrinatory members of the Friars that Mr. Eaton had to “go"’ in response to certain of his animadversions on plays a number of managers got together and agreed to withdraw their theatrical advertising from the Sun. Theatrical advertising is a big item in the revenues of any New York paper. It runs somctimes to two pages on Sunday and the rate is 50 cents a line or $7 per inch, and there are two thousand one hundred lines or one hun dred and fifty inches to the page, equaling $1,050 per page. The withdrawal of such patronage, therefore, is in the nature of a sockdolager answer to criticism which finds fault with plays because of defects in ethical or xsthetic purpose Mr. Eaton is a scholarly critic because or performance and urbane. He is no slasher nor slater. His attitude toward the drama 1s not finical or cynical. But now and again as a conscientious critic who saw what was going on in the management of the American drama he condemned the principles and apparent purposes of that management. He was bold enough even to applaud that part of Wil liam Winter's last book on stage and players, in which the dean of dramatic crities condemned the spirit of theatre management to-day. When he did this, a correspondent in New York sent Mr. Eaton's comment to the editor of the Mir- ror with a memorandum containing this: “ Poor Eaton. The Syndicate will get him for this sort of thing. Watch!"" And while we watched came the strong intimation in Lire. There is enough force in this fortuitous concatenation of coincidence to justify us in adverting again to our theme of the “Myth of a Free Press.”’ Plainly there can't be a free press in a city like New York, when an honest criticism of the methods of the Theatrical Trust—criticism, mind you, and not vituperative abuse—renders the critic liable to discharge Lecause his employers cannot withstand the pressure of the withdrawal of Theatrical Trust advertising. It is enough to make one doubt whether there can be much (e Continued on pare 73 ) Perfect Xmas Gift Reautiful Angora Kittens. Specimens of highest breeding. Charming manners and dispositions. Eaguiste coloring. All ages and colors. Price, $10 to 623. Salely sent by express. Ill clre- 100. ‘Walnut Ridge Farms Co., Box 2028, Boston, Mass, mm In_ addition | KNAPP-FELT De Luxe hats are Six Dollars—Knapp-Felts are Four Dollars, everywhere. Write for “The Hatman.”” |THE CROFUT & KNAPP CO. | BROADWAY, AT THIRTEENTH STREET, NEW YORK will say THE EVE RUBBER: Many amin The Boston Travel Society Old World Journeys ROUND THE _ $1425 WORLD able Four Months? Tou Magnificent Steam- hips; First Clam throughout. comicbooks.com