Life, 1907-12-19 · page 4 of 28
Life — December 19, 1907 — page 4: what you’re looking at
What you’re looking at
This page's main article critiques literary standards through the lens of library censorship. The piece discusses Deacon John Hanlon of Connecticut, who attempted to prohibit his public library from purchasing novels for one year, arguing "trashy literature" corrupts youth. The author defends American novelists' right to equal treatment, arguing that selective exclusion based on moral judgment sets a dangerous precedent. The piece suggests the deacon's reasoning—that librarians should deny taxpayers access to books deemed objectionable—is fundamentally flawed. The satire criticizes moral gatekeeping in early 20th-century America, when anxiety about popular fiction's influence on young readers was widespread. The article advocates for intellectual freedom and questions who gets to decide what's "unsuitable."
📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)
Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.
HUNTER BALTIMORE RYE THE STANDARD OF EX- CELLENCI OF STRAIGHT RYE WHIS- KIES. THE AMERICAN GENTLEMAN'S WHISKEY. Sql at all ratclass cafes and by Jobbers ML LANAHAN & SON, Baltimore, Md. Porto Rico | The special tours of The New York & Porto Rico| Steamship Co. occupy three weeks, and are ideal yachting excursions on summer seas, The steamers have every convenience, with only outside staterooms. They circle the entire island and stop at many interesting and historic localities. The ship is the tourist's hotel during the entire trip, so that the labor and inconvenience of land travel is avoided. The special tourist rate for this cruise is $140, which includes every expense. Weite for illustrated booklet. THE NEW YORK & PORTO RICO STEAMSHIP CO. 12 Broadway, New York, or Raymond & Whitcomb Co., New York, and all Principal Cities Suppose we could furnish you a better tobacco than you ever tried, for less money? Interest you, wouldn't it? Our booklet, free, will prove our claim. Dept. 11, Wilda Tobacco Co., Chatham, Va. PLAYING CARDS A Patented Playing with a handsome reproduction ct @ hremsthiched linen handkerchief on the tack. Colors—Red, live. een, Brown. 2§ cents, Gold eige ag ernis. Of all dealers or the manutacturcrs Radcliffe & Co., New York, 144 Pearl St., &London. E.C. Mackaye’s rare gi ing in the un- literary atmosphere of Cornish, yet stead- fast in the pursuit of an ideal—should see a year’s labor lost, largely through the in- competence of ‘actors unschooled in the utterance of verse. For Mr. Mackaye, let it be understood, is not satisfied to write a book drama, and sees only failure in its failure as an acted play. * * HE poetic play has, of late, given prom- ise of a renaissance. Was that promise premature, and must it be, once more, confined to the closet? We have our own opinions, but it is not for us to usurp the functions of dramatic criticism, which has delivered its verdict somewhat copiously. ‘The advantage of prose over verse as a medium of intellectual communication with the public is strikingly shown in the New York correspondence of the Washing- ton Times, apropos of the subject in hand. We must content ourselves with a too brief excerpt: We can believe nearly anything—even this poct’s tale—of Sappho’s capacity for passion. But is it what we want? Is it what ¢ are looking for? Docs it satisfy? No. It isa beautiful picture. And it is archaic. The theatre of to-day can do more than that. Kalich can pulsate with more vital matters that will teach us about life and how to live. This is a fable that makes you feel, some way, that the whole mythical idea has whiskers on it, A Burning Question HE circulating library as an evergreen tree of diabolical knowledge has in- vited repressive measures from a modern Sir Anthony Absolute—Deacon John Han- lon, of the t Baptist Church, of Nor- walk, Conn. Deacon John has been de- feated, says a news report, in his endeavor to prohibit the Norwalk Public Library from purchasing novels for a period of one year, on the ground that trashy “litera- ture” is perverting the minds of youth. ‘The good deacon has a better case than Sir Anthony, in the England of his day, could have presented from the evidence at hand. He seems, moreover, to have recog: nized that, as all American novelists, at st, are born free and equal, it would be unconstitutional to exercise a discrimina- ting taste in the purchase of our chief literary product—a process of selective exclusion would never do. * * ® HAT such reasoning is by no means purely academic, we can testify on the strength of our private information; it has come to us, from first-hand sources, that one of the foremost librarians of this coun- try seriously questions his right to deny any book not actually vicious to the readers whose taxes go to support the library. We were rather inclined to join hands 140, growing under the very brow of snow-capped mountains, while the seashore, the picturesque forestsand valleys presentall the joys of summer. The journey to this beautiful coast- land is most pleasant on The Overland Limited of the Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Ry. The trains of this company hold the attention of two continents as most pala- tial and luxurious meansof travel. They are electriclighted throughout,and offer unapproached service in dining, sleeping and library-observation cars. The Overland Limited leaves Union Pas- senger Station, Chicago, 6.05 p.m., arriving California in threedays. Another splemtid train at 10.10 p.m., with through standard and touristsleepers. Descriptive literature free upon addressing F. A, MILLER, Genceat Passtxcee Acrut, Curcaco, on W. S. MOWELL, Gow. Easrens Act.,381 B'war.New Yors on Camden Heights CAMDEN, SOUTH CAROLINA T. EDMUND KRUMBHOLZ THE KIRKWOOD |An Ideal Winter Climate BERMUDA Onty 4g hours from New Yer by frequent steamers of Quebec S (29 bros Me, Yachting, Driving Coif, Se ightfut throughout the whater. The wellanc#n Princess Hotel OPENS DECEMBER 9th “THE IDEAL WINTER RESORT” bath | HOWE & TWOROGER, Mgrs., Hamilton, Bermuda comicbooks.com