Life, 1907-06-20 · page 27 of 32
Life — June 20, 1907 — page 27: what you’re looking at
What you’re looking at
This page is primarily **advertisements and editorial content**, not political cartoons. The main text is a serious essay by Charles W. Lamed defending military education (specifically West Point) as superior to civilian college education. **The argument**: Lamed contends that West Point successfully develops character, physical fitness, and civic duty—following the Greek educational ideal—whereas colleges focus only on mind and technical training while ignoring moral development. He cites West Point graduates' success in civilian fields (presidents, senators, judges, etc.) as proof the military system works. **The Life editor's response** (in brackets) disputes this, arguing that *less* coercive civilian education actually produces more capable citizens who can make independent choices. The page also features period advertisements for liqueur, ale, and a "Don't-Snore" anti-snoring device—typical of early 20th-century magazines. **For modern readers**: This reflects a historical debate about whether authoritarian discipline or individual freedom better prepares citizens, with the magazine taking the progressive side favoring autonomy.
📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)
Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.
MOST DELICIOUS OF ALL CORDIALS LIQUEUR Peres Chartreux —GREEN AND YELLOW— Known as Chartreuse At Snitclass Wine Merchants, Grocers, Hotel Batjer & Co., 45 Broadway, New York, Ys Sole Agents for United States. A Picnic in the woods and a supply of Evans Ale —that’s the way to at- tain happiness Motoring 40 miles an hour won't fart Evans’ Ale. “Don’t-Snore” PATENT, TRADEMARK REGISTERED A simple device to prevent snoring and make you breathe erooerly, Soon breaks you of sleeping with mouth open. Apcroved by athletes and singers. Gold Filled, $1.00 ? Wet sen SIMPLE DEVICE Co. cern itself with the relation of the individual to the State and to society, and that a culture which is purely individualistic and selfish will produce a corresponding social condition, with ideals, habits and beliefs that do not make for righteousness or the common good— . witness our social system and current events. That the genius of modern education since the Humanists of the Renaissance has been concerned almost wholly with mind culture and of late, also, with the bread and butter sciences and technical training, and has prac- tically ignored the development of character and body as systematic objectives; whereas the Greeks, whose literature has been our fetich for centuries, made the main purpose of their educational system the building of char- acter, physical development and the duties of tizenship, and crowned their decidedly coer- cive scheme of education with from two to four years of ephebic training, in which their youth were cadets in a military academy, where their final examinations were in the duties of citizenship and arts of war. That the military school is about the only one which to-day consistently, and of pur- pose, exercises these three functions and seeks to develop what Montaigne calls the whole man, through discipline of morals, mind and body, and personal accountability for every act. You will do me the justice to observe that I do not assume the military school or training to have attained ideal success in all these par- ticulars, nor that its special coercive methods are wholly adapted to civil uses. I merely invite attention to the fact that here is a mechanism which, within its limits and for its purposes, is fulfilling the Greck ideal. I would like to add my personal belief that a skeleton of these coercive fundamentals could underlie the body of civil education and still leave room for free development of initiative and personality. In conclusion, there seems to me some food for reflection in the fact that since its estab- lishment, one-half of the graduates of West Point have entered civil life and have attained distinction in every field of endeavor as Presi- dents, Senators, Governors of States and Prov- inces, Ambassadors, presidents and chancel- lors of universities and colleges, bishops, Mayors, authors, editors, surveyors, bankers, presidents of railroads and corporations, mer- chants, farmers and many more; besides do- ing pretty well in their own line when they are “adjusted to the requirements of a rigid system.” Cuarzes W. Larnep. [In its remarks on Colonel Lamed’s ad- dress Lirr extenuated the education offered by the colleges, on the ground that being less coercive than the West Point education it better qualified the youth who really profited by it to make his own choices, shape the details of his own conduct and be responsible for the event. West Pointers, it is true, have succeeded in many fields of civil life, but in most cases, we believe, they have shown the defects as well as the ad- vantages of West Point education. And how many men of notable talent, like Whistler and Poe, have been dropped out of West Point because the Procrustean system of that place was not fitted for the A LITTLE STORY Simply Told ofa BIG SUCCESS Based on Simple Merit For many years and in many strange corners of the world I bad smoked cigarets. None of those made in Turkey, Egypt, Western Europe, or the Orient were just the “real thing,” and not until I learned it from Russians, did I know the true delight ofa perfect cigaret smoke. Thad a friendly and honest desiro to contribute something to the luxury of living, and, believing this Russian Cigaret to bo the best in the world, and very far in advance of anything ever offered in America, I began a few months ago to manofacture them in a small wa: and to furnish them to my friends and their friends. I felt sure that smokers could and would discriminate if given an oppor- tunity. And t guessed right. In tho beginning I offered Makaroff Russian Cigarets to tho consumer only, Buch aa insist- Tappeal came to me, almost at once, from nokers throughout America to place these cig+ a hin their convenient reach, that I was ractically forced, six mouths ago, to begin to jot dealers have them, Never, since dealers were given an opporto- nity tostdck thesocigarots, has the factory been anywhere near equal to the demande upon it. Buch cigarets cannot be grund out by ma: ‘The men who make Makaroff Cigarets must be Russians of life-long training—artists at their work, Go it is that merit, backed by faith in 9 dis- criminating public, has won—again, and our sales have outrun odr most strenuous olforta at For a time, therefore. our ing will be digcontinued~ San cateteup to ourorderenand tis inoue ‘tanouncement for the present. Gdly, wo aball advertiea again when w Daveoolved the problemof adequate production. Tho quality of our cigarete will not be allowed to deteriorate because the orders are stacked BD. This lee connoisseurs: business and will be opt wo. In conclusion: The manufacture and distri- bation of these cigarets has quickly ‘4 pleasant pastime fora few friends business and a * main issue,” but it hi the savor of enthusiasm and good intentions, Ask for these cigareta at high-grade tobacco- you cannot get thera atouce, be patient, ike.to.ua if you really ca tie skcop aamall reserve of the bores of on \dred, packed in cedar, tomers, old. aad new, W Gne hundred, with or without the distinctive Russian mouiliplece or tubs, at dred—and your money back ins Minot any elgnrots, it they fal te utmost expectations, Dealers sol Hussian Cigarets in three grades, ot 15) CENTS @:@® IN BOXES OF TEN to sat! 4 Makarod Respectfully—and Gratefally, Makaroff Co. of America Suite 152 95 Milk St., Boston, Mass. Rose-Cold A MONOGRAPH of interest. containing practical facts with- out theories and fancies. sent free upon request. Dr. Walter C. Brotoning 1325 Spruce St., Philadelphia, Pa. development of their talents!—Eprtor.] 8st comicbooks.com