Life, 1905-05-11 · page 23 of 26
Life — May 11, 1905 — page 23: what you’re looking at
What you’re looking at
This article criticizes the Theatrical Managers' Association's boycott of Life magazine's drama critic (apparently named Metcalfe) after he published a cartoon the court ruled legitimate. Though Life won the libel case, the theatre trust retaliated by banning him from all forty theatres they controlled. Life condemns this as censorship and corporate abuse of power. The article argues the managers invented a secondary issue—that Metcalfe had criticized Jewish people—to justify the ban, when the real motive was silencing press criticism. Life frames this as un-American: a powerful monopoly depriving a man of livelihood and denying the public access to honest dramatic criticism, all to avoid accountability. The satire targets corporate intimidation of the press and scapegoating of minorities as pretext for suppressing dissent.
📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)
Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.
> -LIFE- erican industri KNOX HAT » creation par excellence of the nation Spring styles now ready. Agencies in a rincipal cities In the world. Coaching days have come. Correct liveries for road and pate; where. Mlustrated price asking. for any manservant any- “ist for the ROGERS, PEET & CO., 258—842—1260 Broadway, (3 Stores) NEW YORK. erybody knows ‘‘Corticelli”’ is the best silk for sewing, stitching, crocheting, art pessle work. Mountmellick and Hardanger end qc. in stamps for our let, ‘Lessons in Embroidery.” Address icelli Silk Mills, 46 Nonotuck St.. Florence, Mass. The Wag. H S laughest best who laugheth last. > on the mundane ball, The dog, who chuckles with his tail, Must laugh the best of all. —Houston ( Texas) Post, A High-handed Attempt to Stifle Honest Criticism. FTER the Court had decided that the pub- lication of the cartoon in the interests of human life and the rightful protection of jthe people was legitimate and right in view f the facts brought out in the case, the heatri Managers’ Association passed a [resolution barring Mr. Metcalfe from all of |the forty theatres which the association con- trolled. Here is an overt act so so dangerous in influence a precedent, that it should not be pe d to go un- challenged. .A public journal, true to the high Jdemands of journalism, incurs the wrath of certain members of a well-nigh all-powerful | Theatrical Trust. They seek to silence the paper through a libel suit, but the evidence is so overwhelming in its character that they lose |the suit. Then, fi to silence the press where honest criticism is most demanded— that is, where human life is in jeopardy—they go into the Managers’ Association and secure the passage of the odious and un-American | resolution boycotting the dramatic critic of Lire. True, the Trust did not dare to attack Lire and its critic thus boldly and directly. It evidently did not feel that the American press was yet quite complacent enough to ignore h a high-handed outrage. So they con- re up a new issue and give as a reason for barring Mr. Metealfe from the theatres, that Lire has criticised certain Jews; and, we sup- pose chiefly because the master-spirits of the Theatrical Trust happen to be Hebrews. they insist that because Lire has assailed certain Hebrews, therefore Mr, Metcalfe, the dra- matic critic of Lire, is to be barred from the theatres of New York, Here an issue is raised entirely foreign to the real grievance. But even if the contention were true, which is not the case, what do the American people think of this high-handed outr: and the precedent it establishes? Here is the amusement-loving public of New York in the hands of an association or group in character, |of men arrogating to themselves the right to bar citizens from the houses of amusement and depriving a man of his means of livelihood, because it is alleged t the journal with which the party in question is associated has assailed a certain race or some members of that race—The Arena. cn sett <i f Shirt is adapted to any figure, and goes ‘on and comes off like a coat. Extensive variety of coloted fabrics—colors fast. $1.50 and more CLUETT, PEABODY & CO, Makers of Cluettand Arrow Col Kid Gloves. SOFT, Elastic, Durable. Silk Gloves. Remarkable for Finish and Beauty of Texture. 50¢., 75¢., $1.00. 31 years on Broadway. CENTEMERI 911 Broadway, just above 20th St ‘Telephone: i135 Gramercy. $1.50. A Catalogue of PARISIAN ART PHOTOS with 450 Mlustrations is sent Post Free for 50 cents in stamps of any country. Sample collections of Photos at $1.00, $2.00, $5.00, ete. H. WEISS, - 23 Rue d'Enghien, Paris, France. ware = MADE LINEN 15¢ EACH ARABIC (F YOUR DEALER WONT SUPPLY YOU, WRITE US EMIGH & STRAUB-Dept CC.TROY,NY OLD CROW RYE sido: WHISKEY soe se SS voen, comicbooks.com