Life, 1905-02-09 · page 16 of 22
Life — February 9, 1905 — page 16: what you’re looking at
What you’re looking at
This page from *Life* magazine satirizes theatrical industry power dynamics, specifically targeting the "Theatrical Trust" (likely Klaw and Erlanger, major theater monopolists of the era). The central cartoon depicts a figure wielding large scissors, appearing to cut theatrical productions. The accompanying commentary—presented as debate among newspapers—discusses editor Metcalfe's criticism of theater managers who control New York's dramatic output. The satire centers on how these monopolists suppress unfavorable reviews and control which plays get staged. The various quoted newspaper responses defend *Life's* right to publish theatrical criticism without fear of retaliation, while mocking managers' attempts to silence negative press. The joke is that despite the Trust's power to bar critics from theaters, they cannot actually prevent publications from writing about them. The cartoonist ridicules both the theatrical monopoly's heavy-handed censorship attempts and the absurdity of trying to suppress free speech through intimidation.
📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)
Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.
THE REVISED VERSION The queen of hearts, She me tarts, All on a winter day She had a mood For breakfast food, Ithem full of hi So stutfe The ki He called for tarts, The queen just rules; She never With cooking Liovp Oso once invited a friend to visit h His 6 J said that not! ing would give h how do you get to Samoa, anyhow? * responded Stevenson, "You s to Americ #8 the continent to San Fr the seco Harper's Weekly. to the left Iris reported, says an exchange, that one of our n married Ia eson, T The kneads bread with her ¢ dent may be peculiar, but there are others. er needs bread with his shoes on; bread without so much as ar of Eden, either, ia the winter time yb A REST ANO ARREST. “ Thaven’t seen your cashier for several days."" 0; he’s gone out of town. ' gone for a rest c WILSON WHISKEY mpany, Bi Tost: Why are you so > sore at old otrox? You talk as if you had received some insult at his hands. Dick from him had care so much, Lr Russia (on see) THINK TVR al dant suitor of Miss Gi ): Ifthe insule ands" I wouldn't been at his hange. 1s To ke WHY, 1 COULD EAT MI. —Judy. “Tun editor of Lu York theatres by the ex That’s All! Newsdealers in Great Bri Chancery Lane, Lo d from the awnbrokers and suspender ped- had been b ‘The Internati F.C, F | AN does not live by bread alone — it quires the assistance of Ale to overcome the mono of food and promote essen and matter st to happiness and longe It is rich in all the essentials th | to make a health nerve-making, body-building beve | an ideal drink for every time. Any Dealer soy Places Evans’ harmony of mind conducive satisf yin, all the dlers who control the drama in that city because he has dared to tell the truth concerning theatricals in the m lis. If there were more editors like Metcalfe and pers like Live, the Theatrical T de bunco steering and F entirely separate oc terprite st would de ENTIRELY TRUE * Ibis not proved, however, that Lire has willfully mig stated the facty as to the merits or demerits of any Klaw and Erlanger productions. It is not likely that any periodical or newspaper would be able to effectively pur polic tions efforts as agents’ 03 of misrepresentation for any length of time, Pu sue that policy find their tra NOT WORTH THE TROU “If T were Metcalfe, forty-seven theatres, I don't thi Lare’s dra excladed pk the lawyers 6 fr get any of my money i lot of fun w Paterson Press. ainst managers, Vd havea iskers and other wigs, false w “Tue theatrical managerial oped any men of large cal power to close pr ness has never devel bre. A man who would HI the public places aga ored a grudge, is te of respectable and decent men.”— Vi, Standard. editor for whom he h: » conten despicable for the no Wa own, N “Ip Me. Metcalfe had declared that Mr. Erlanger is a Jew, we judge he would have been guilty of misrepresca- tation, and a fit subject for reprehension. He said he a Jew, and he és; why, therefore, complain? "—Harper's Tur managers claim that they can refus that person objection: t to the color of a man’s h; Scranton Tribs any person They ' admittance if they co insist that they can the shape of his necktie. “THe rical Trust in common with other trusts sought to pu of judgment in its manner of procedure.” Thea sh its enemy, but it seems to be utterly void —Pittsfield Ea, “Ly this way dramatic criticism in Gotham is made to s, and the public is kept guessing.""—i/a re- Established 150 Varieties Steel Pens tony that | vity. ity Sold Everywhere The Best Pens Made hat. go comicbooks.com