Life — December 15, 1904 — page 12: what you’re looking at

What you’re looking at

# Analysis of Life Magazine Page 624 This is a drama criticism page titled "Heredity Again to the Fore." The article discusses American actors performing in plays from the "dissection school of drama"—realistic theatre that differs from traditional Shakespeare performances. The profile illustration appears to be **Sothern** (name visible below the sketch), likely Edward Sothern, a prominent actor of the era. The text critiques how actors in naturalistic plays become "weird and unnatural," arguing they overemphasize method and delivery. It specifically mentions performances in "Fires of St. John" by actors including Miss Nance O'Neil, praising some while questioning whether excessive realism serves the material. The article suggests the plays' "gloomy and abnormal" stories force actors into exaggerated performances, creating unintended comedy rather than drama. It's essentially defending traditional acting against emerging naturalistic techniques.