Judge, 1925-05-09 · page 4 of 36
Judge — May 9, 1925 — page 4: what you’re looking at
What you’re looking at
# Analysis of Judge Magazine Page 2 This page satirizes New York City life and attitudes toward other American cities. The top cartoon mocks "Harlem Home Life" and "Uptown Holdup," depicting chaotic street scenes with exaggerated characters along Manhattan's skyline. The main cartoon below shows a stranger asking directions to "Forty-second and Broadway," apologizing for being a "Gentile." This likely references New York's Jewish population and ethnic neighborhoods of the era. The accompanying text sections titled "Funnyboner" and "On All Walks of Life" mock New York's crowded, chaotic streets, beggars, and social disorder. The final sections explain why residents of Chicago, Pittsburgh, San Francisco, and Los Angeles resent New York—characterizing it as "too aggressive," "too selfish," and "too progressive," while "they're *not* New York," implying superiority tinged with defensive mockery.
📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)
Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.
My new, act is knbckin‘em dead | iszat so? SSS Rive =—O ~ | — AMERICA'S Sight-seeing Fi b On All Walks of Life Dos in Havana they have boats unns oes / 11, the sidewalks of New York- with glass bottoms so you can You can take a chorus girl out of On the sidewalks of New York: see the fish, Along Broadway they | the “Fe ” but you can't take Pastrami, salami and butts, have rubbervneck wagons’ with glass tops so the fish can sce. It alll evens dp in the'end. CC. the follies out of a chorus girl : : fe ‘ fe pital Spumoni, bologny and mutts, | \s ap iapatap ten 85 for Gach one pron Rovgh guys and tough guys galore, A “shoppe” where there should be a store; Beggars, bootleggers and tramps, Petite little, sweet little vamps; | Collusion, confusion and muss, Collision, derision and fuss; Espousal, carousal, distress, In general, the same sort of mess As London, Toronto or Cork You'll find on the streets of New York! A. L. L. Why New Yorkers Hate Chi- cago, Pittsburgh, San Francisco and Los Angeles B” avsF. these cities are too aggres- sive, too complacent, too selfish, too self-centered, too progressive. Because they ape New York and get away with it. Because they're not New York. Why Chicago, Pittsburgh, San Fran- cisco and Los Angeles Hate New York: — | Because New York is too aggres- sive, too complacent, too selfish, too self-centered, too progressive. Be- | cause New York apes them and gets | First Strancer—Can you direct me to Forty-second and Broadway? away with it. Because they're not “Sorry—I'm a Gentile myself.” New York. | comicbooks.com