Judge, 1923-04-14 · page 4 of 36
Judge — April 14, 1923 — page 4: what you’re looking at
What you’re looking at
# Analysis of "Another Menace" This illustration by Gilbert Wilkinson depicts a domestic dispute about family trees and genealogy research. The story "Another Menace" by Grantland Rice satirizes the growing craze of genealogy—tracing family ancestry—as a threat to domestic harmony. The scene shows a husband confronting his wife about her genealogy obsession. She's become so consumed researching family history (specifically seeking information about "Mr. Neurich" regarding "mushrooms") that she neglects household duties and social propriety. The husband's complaints—that she spends money, ignores him, and embarrasses the family publicly—mock how genealogy became an absorbing hobby that could disrupt middle-class marriages and domestic order. The satire targets the era's genealogy fad as creating marital discord.
📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)
Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.
Drawn by Gitaent WILKINSON “I want to see Mr. Neurich about th’ mushrooms—” “Oh, you're the man that’s working on the family tree.” Another Menace by Gardner Rea ‘0 THINK it required a fire right in our own hotel to make me re that 'y last stronghold of personal liberty sing knocked sky high! And by the ! However, I never was very quick at things. I suppose I really owe my discovery to Millicent; just as Sir Isaac owed his to the apple. But the first cause was the fire. It broke right in on the middle y insomnia. And as my wife is ever id sleeper, I applied an old trick I learned from having horses run away with me in the army. I reached over and shut off her wind. Slowly her sub- consciousness struggled upward. ire!” I cried. ! Firel” “Well,” yawned Millicent, “I don’t want it, put it out.” I paused not to bandy words. Grab- bing my one-piece design closer about me, I sprang for the door. “Heavens, Alfred,” gurgled Millicent, “not like that! I never realized how cunning you looked! Just like a Wool’s Soap ad.” Goaded to sarcasm, I paused. “It’s merely the contrast, my dear,” I said icily. “Adonis himself would be out of it, compared with those patent curlers of yours.” 2 “Just so,” said Millicent calmly. “I to ta m off. If you think either of us is going to plunge out in public looking like a fright—” “But what’s the odds? N see us. Nobody who counts, anyway “Oh, won't they! How about — the ? Do you realize that those beastly cameras have probal Saturday night we'd be the whole world. Just like with your face dirty Nothing doing, my dear, we doll up first!” So, in the face of such a menace chancing possible premature death rather (Continued on page 2 stock of the being buried in ice,