Judge — December 2, 1922 — page 17: what you’re looking at

What you’re looking at

This is a film criticism column by Ruth Hale reviewing Valentine's latest picture, "The Young Rajah." The page critiques actor Rudolph Valentino's performance and screen presence. The illustrated header shows a fashionable woman viewing a film scene with a man on a bench labeled "GREAT," suggesting the page's focus on evaluating romantic leading men. Hale discusses whether Valentino deserves his reputation as a great screen actor, arguing his appeal relies heavily on physical beauty and expression rather than genuine acting ability. She compares him unfavorably to Charlie Chaplin and favorably notes Mary Pickford's discovery talent. The piece debates whether Valentino's "deep conviction" and faith in himself can overcome his limited dramatic range—a contemporary debate about whether movie stardom requires authentic talent or merely photogenic appeal.