Judge, 1922-08-19 · page 5 of 36
Judge — August 19, 1922 — page 5: what you’re looking at
What you’re looking at
# Analysis of Judge Magazine Page **The Cartoon (top):** Drawn by Gilbert Wilkinson, this sketch shows two figures in an artist's studio. The dialogue satirizes the struggle for artistic recognition: a "Soulful Girl" complains that artists never receive fair reward, while a "Cynical Artist" cynically responds that success requires committing "murder or some such thing." **The Article (below):** "Clear, Cold Logic and the Irish Question" by Gardner Rea presents a dialogue between characters named Millivent and an Irish person (not clearly identified). The conversation appears to mock Irish stereotypes and political positions on Irish independence, using the characters' exchange to satirize both Irish politics and American attitudes toward the "Irish Question"—a major political issue of the early 20th century. The satire targets both artistic pretension and Irish political discourse.
📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)
Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.
weather. nothing like rich, re cont. mean. mich long a moment of thot “are who frantic; n by GILBERT WILKINSON. Soulful Girl—You know, I never think any artist ever gets his just reward. Cynical Artist—They do occasionally. I believe one has to commit murder or some such thing to get it. Clear, Cold Logic and the Irish Question HANK goodness we shan’t hear le: | much more of the Irish Question,” — dif remarked Millicent suddenly. “Hot you know.” “Yes.” TE replied urcastically, “there's co strawberries for—” “Dont be absurd.” retorted Milli- “You know perfectly well what I They simply can’t’ wear them adi an Ur Grown wise with experience, I waited fhough To must admit [rather pity those poor Ulsterites,” she went on, after ht. “Emagine illing people just: because they don't dress to it had come. 5.” LE explained — patiently, as you seem to think, people ly insist upon being per- to go about in ulsters. Ulster is not, 1 Millicent bel- * inquir “It doesn’t mean anything. It doesn’t to.” “OF course not! T might have known. » second a thing means anything, poli- won't “Politi Millicent, is nof mere say, intelligence pers logically. by Gardner R It is simply sign ferent type of intelligence “Em not intuitive.” retort Kdly. °T think—clearly, Though IT) must ded, o blunderin, Trish bull ina china sl tited States shop either.” She—You ought to give it affects the heart. — He—By that reasoning, give you up, too. ea lificant to a or Ln not intuition.” ed Millicent coldly and say.” she rout like Nor a op. up smoking I ought to frightful continued Millicent an Trish bull—” . t at sing to tell me,” suspiciously, “that =” Treplied hastily, “they're eatures!” “They're symbolic of the whole Trish race— “People is enough, my dear. spoil them —T about destructively, look- Don't ing for anything red “Orange.” And utterly oblivion Millicent, in a burst of the color of their own hair “Which they hide in the sanc gested helpfully, “at the hunt * concluded iration, “to T sug- ap- jealous,” said Millicent sweet- Iv. SIU such a lovely figure: and Pm sure it explains the whele Irish problem perfectly.” “In view of the fact that your mother was born a Duffy,” Lagreed, “it probably does.” : Millicent, It “is un- mean retorted political. doesn’t ly returned to my paper. “Then when will your Irish political