Judge, 1919-10-11 · page 24 of 36
Judge — October 11, 1919 — page 24: what you’re looking at
What you’re looking at
This page is primarily **music criticism and advertising**, not political satire. It reviews newly released phonograph recordings for the Disco label, a common feature in Judge magazine during the early phonograph era. The central image shows **Patricia Collina**, a recording artist, with a caption explaining she has "won—proves that even the best talking machine record can't give everything." This appears to be humorous commentary on performers whose personality exceeds what the limited phonograph technology could capture. The reviews discuss popular songs of the era—waltzes, jazz numbers, and sentimental pieces—performed by artists like Arthur Fields and Billy Murray. The humor is gentle, focusing on the quality of recordings and whether particular songs will achieve popularity. The only clear satire involves observations about market flooding (multiple "Carolina Sunshine" recordings) and the limitation of the new medium itself. **Context for modern readers**: This represents the early 1920s phonograph industry, before electrical recording improved sound quality significantly.
📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)
Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.
a Drown by Hemwax Patan Best of the New Phonog Disco’s SELEcTIONS Vavpevitte Vocal Ka ufman. Oo-ta-ta! Weel Wee! Sung by Arthur Fields. Acolian-Vocalion 12181. Hubby has s' [ Breeze. Sung by Arthur Fields and Jack ed a blowout. His has_ bee: At least, which he can a So he now entreat catchy tune, the sai his stole: rite selections ued them. rivate little conference in France not j~ Gime Tuts, Giase Tua. din the newspape s. Also Pt Sirrtxc Croer Turoven llins and Ha Breeze. Sung by Arthur Fields and Jack Kaufman x ing a dare wh Taxe Me to tue Laxp or Jazz. S Billy Murray. C same Kau he same ditty the Realm of Deliriu such vivid terms and il such ecstat ure he has knows the country like a native. Carounxa Sunsuine. Prerry Lirtie Ratwnow. Sung by ng from the number of c panies that are putting out this America is in process of bein flooded with “Carolina Sunshine.” s aside, it is quite a imental di-ty in waltz ith a dash of “Home, Sweet by way of inte lud pleasingly _ Rainbow,” another re than an also-ran. by Charles Acolian- | Drrasy Arapasa. Hawauan Rose pair of waltz song slightly dreamier Each is infuse spirit. of —hope—Mary hop: that “Dreamy Ala- a” will be as popular as her “Beautiful Ohio,” and Klickman’s Photo by Deries hope that “Hawaiian Rose” will be Patricola—to p as popular as his “Sweet Hawaiian first name, she has wonc--proves that foen the best Moonlight.” talking machine record can't give ezerything. 24 raph Records y acharm x No Tite to Have “st Nor Jeatous and Bill When you record it gen istic he-an that h. street *Mandy ox-trot tem wif by Peerless Quart Henry Burr and lian-}’ocal: Burr and his P sub-titled “A De equipped with the s. palms and {~ Ont On! On! Tose Laxptorns Sung by Irving Kau Oo-ra-tal Wee! Billy Murr. A touch in the fc tion of his Most fervent. Mr. Kaufman gain, The tune is as lively as (Continued on page 34)