Judge — October 18, 1913 — page 4: what you’re looking at

What you’re looking at

# Editorial Cartoons Analysis This page from *Judge* magazine presents three opinion pieces with accompanying illustrations: **"Pies and Cakes"** critiques Missouri's county fair system for judging baked goods. The editorial argues the association should rely on objective standards rather than subjective taste preferences, suggesting women-suffrage societies and animal advocates shouldn't influence judging criteria. **"Conscience"** explores the nature of moral conscience as an "inward ear" guiding human conduct, distinguishing between genuine conscience and mere social fear or reputation concerns. **"Still Thinner"** satirizes men who mock women's fashion choices—specifically the controversy over short skirts and tube silhouettes—while hypocritically pursuing their own sartorial trends. The piece argues fashion choices reflect practical judgment, not foolishness. The illustrations use caricature to emphasize these points about social hypocrisy and arbitrary judgment standards.