Judge — September 25, 1909 — page 1: what you’re looking at

What you’re looking at

# Analysis of Judge Magazine, September 25, 1909 This page uses a dramatic silhouette illustration to promote debate over a proposed federal income tax. The headline "Do You Want It?" frames the central question. The article discusses President Taft's support for an income tax on incomes over $1,200 annually. It presents arguments in favor, noting the tax would be "equitable" and burden-sharing. The piece cites the National Association of Manufacturers' suggestion of a one-eighth of one percent rate. The striking visual—showing a figure peering through a large circular opening at shadowy scenes below—appears designed to make readers contemplate the proposal's implications. The caption "AMERICAN CITIZENS, TAKE NOTICE!!" emphasizes the urgency of public consideration. The page is primarily editorial commentary rather than humor, appealing to citizens to engage with this significant constitutional and fiscal question before Congress.