Judge — October 28, 1905 — page 1: what you’re looking at

What you’re looking at

# Analysis of Judge Magazine Cover, October 28, 1905 This political cartoon satirizes uncertainty about **who will be the next Republican presidential candidate**. Lady Liberty, depicted as Columbia (the allegorical female figure of America), stands confused before a signpost with multiple directional arrows pointing different candidates: - Root, Foraker, Cortelyou, Fairbanks, Herrick, Beveridge, La Follette, Lodge, and Taft The caption "ALL SIGNS POINT ONE WAY" is ironic—the signs actually point every direction, suggesting no consensus exists. This reflects genuine 1905 confusion about **President Theodore Roosevelt's successor**, as the Republican Party debated various candidates before eventually nominating William Howard Taft in 1908.