Judge, 1904-09-24 · page 16 of 16
Judge — September 24, 1904 — page 16: what you’re looking at
What you’re looking at
This page contains two separate comic sketches satirizing American leisure and entertainment. **"Returning from the Horse-Show"** depicts a child asking about prize-winning at a prestigious horse show. The humor plays on class contrast: a working-class man ("Roody the Sport") boasts that his entry won "all de prizes fer de best all-round in his class"—the lower-class qualifier undercutting the prestige. The dialect and character suggest satirizing working-class aspirations to participate in upper-class sporting events. **"Evolution of the Play"** jokes about a theater performance at the opera hall that started as comedy but became tragedy. The punchline references "limed eggs"—rotten eggs audiences threw at bad performances. The satire suggests the show was so poorly received that what began comedically devolved into literal tragedy, with the audience literally pelting the stage. This mocks both poor theatrical quality and audience reaction traditions. Both sketches use class commentary and exaggeration typical of Judge's satirical approach.
📄 Transcribed text from this page (OCR, searchable)
Machine-transcribed from the original scan — historical spelling and the odd misread are preserved.
RETURNING FROM THE HORSE-SHOW. Tommy—' Gee! did he take a prize ?"* Reopy tHe srort—" Wot! did he take a prize? Well, yer bet yer tintype: he took all de prizes fer de best all-round in his class."* CoPrRIEnT 1904 #y JUDGE COMPANY PUBLISMERS, 225 FOURTH AVE. NEW YORE ‘Sachem & Wilhelns Ute & Prg Co NewYorn . EVOLUTION OF THE PLAY. Sitas Jay—'‘ Was that ere show at the opree-hall last night a comedee ?”" ‘Srorexezrer—‘ Well it started in to be a comedy, but, judging from the sale of limed eggs, | reckon it ended in a tragedy." comicbooks.com