Judge — January 21, 1888 — page 1: what you’re looking at

What you’re looking at

# Political Cartoon Analysis: "Is It Coming To This?" (Judge, January 21, 1888) This cartoon depicts politicians sitting in the U.S. Supreme Court, each holding signs listing their complaints and demands for judicial positions or rewards. The figure labeled "Uncle Sam" (representing the nation) observes with alarm. The satire criticizes how politicians treat the Supreme Court as a patronage system—rewarding political loyalists with judicial appointments rather than selecting justices based on merit. The politicians' signs reference various grievances and entitlements ("I deserve a seat," "Reward me"), suggesting they view Supreme Court positions as political spoils. The caption warns that allowing this practice could turn the Court into "a Hospital for superannuated politicians"—essentially a retirement home for worn-out party operatives—compromising judicial independence.