Sabrina the Teenage Witch #55

Sparks are clearly flying in Sabrina the Teenage Witch #55, as the cover — penciled and inked by Holly Golightly — shows Sabrina and a blue-haired young man named Shinji drawn close together in an intimate, almost-nose-to-nose moment, a note clutched between them hinting at feelings neither may be ready to say out loud. The cover teases the burning question right out loud: "Is there magic between Sabrina & Shinji?!" Whether that magic is the supernatural kind or the romantic kind — or both — is exactly what makes this 2004 Archie Comics issue so fun to pick up.