comicbooks.com Join Free
All Star Western #84 cover
Cover: Gil Kane & Joe Giella

All Star Western #84

Aug 1955 · DC · 0.10 USD
☆ Be the first to review + Add to your collection — Join free

In "The Trail of the Twisters!", Strong Bow returns to a valley under siege by Running Buffalo’s warriors, who drive out a peaceful tribe. With cunning and a clever ruse—faking footprints with one moccasin and sending a message floating with the other—he outwits the invaders. The story, written by Ed Herron and illustrated by Jerry Grandenetti, features bold, dynamic artwork and a cleverly plotted showdown, culminating in a symbolic trade where the chief keeps the moccasins that helped win the war. The cover, by Gil Kane with inks by Joe Giella, captures the tension and drama of the tale.

Contains 6 stories
The Trail of the Twisters!
6 pp · Western-Frontier
Trigger Twins

In "The Trail of the Twisters!" from All Star Western #84, the Twister Gang strikes during tornado season, vanishing into the dust after raiding banks in the wreckage. When Walt tracks a suspicious store owner only to be trapped in Echo Canyon by echoing hoofbeats, his brother Wayne rides ahead to a town ravaged by storms, ready to confront the gang and free him.

Untitled Non-Fiction story
0.5 pp · Non-Fiction, Western-Frontier
The Moccasins That Won a War!
6 pp · Western-Frontier

In a tale of cunning and legend, the chief keeps a pair of Strong Bow’s moccasins hanging in his lodge—proof of a victory that changed the valley’s fate. When Running Buffalo’s warriors overrun the land, driving out the peaceful, Strong Bow returns not with a war cry, but with a plan, using only one moccasin’s shadow and the other’s message to turn the tide.

Indian Pipe Ritual!
0.67 pp · Non-Fiction, Western-Frontier
Threat of the Aztec Athletes!
6 pp · Western-Frontier

In "Threat of the Aztec Athletes!" from All Star Western #84, a tense peace is tested when Aztec warriors and Cavalrymen compete in a display of horsemanship, their mutual suspicion barely masked by the rules of fair play. When Lt. Foley spots a figure raiding the fort office during a race, the fragile truce begins to unravel—sparked not by war, but by a townsman’s greed, who stokes fear to profit from selling rifles to the Aztecs, all while pretending to champion peace.

The Surprise Sheriff!
6 pp · Western-Frontier
Johnny Thunder [John Tane]

In "The Surprise Sheriff!" from All Star Western #84 (1955), schoolteacher John—secretly the masked vigilante Johnny Thunder—finds himself thrust into the role of sheriff when his father, Sheriff Tane, is felled by the outlaw Dry Gulch Gang. With the town counting on him, John must step out from behind his books and don the identity of the Western Whirlwind, using quick thinking and a daring escape to take on the gang.

ComicBooks.com Value

Our Model is In Beta
Raw (Good) $27
CGC 9.0 · 1 in census $327*
CGC 8.5 none in existence
CGC 8.0 · 1 in census $179*
CGC 7.5 · 1 in census $144*
CGC 7.0 none in existence
CGC 6.5 none in existence
Show all 15 grades
CGC 6.0 · 1 in census $87*
CGC 5.5 none in existence
CGC 5.0 none in existence
CGC 4.5 none in existence
CGC 4.0 none in existence
CGC 3.5 none in existence
CGC 3.0 · 1 in census $41*
CGC 2.5 none in existence
CGC 2.0 · 1 in census $30*
* estimate — limited direct-sales data at this grade
Our model’s value — refined as new sales data arrives · CGC census counts shown where available

This exact issue on

CGC 3 $70.66 1 listing
Verified matches for All Star Western #84 · eBay asking prices, seen 29 days ago

Sell my copy

Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.

We Buy Collections ▸
Fast, fair offers · we handle grading & shipping

Full credits

writer Ed Herron
artist, inker Jerry Grandenetti
cover pencils Gil Kane
cover inks Joe Giella

Reprints

Reprinted in Seriemagasinet #7/1958 (1958), Seriemagasinet #9/1958 (1958), Seriemagasinet #2/1959 (1959), The Hundred Comic Monthly #30 (1959), All Favourites, The 100-Page Comic #13 (1959), All Favourites Comic #17 (1960), Tomahawk #131 (1970), Tomahawk #9/1971 (1971), Tomahawk #9/1971 (1971)

Reviews

Reader reviews

No reader reviews yet.